Farmers in Thakurgaon, the north-western border district of Bangladesh, were busy planting early potatoes in early November 2024 on land newly cleared of transplanted aman rice, Jagonews24 reported on 9 November 2024. The aman harvest and threshing had not yet finished in the district's five upazilas, but growers who plant an early crop every year in the hope of extra profit had already moved on to potatoes. This season they did so at a risk: seed, fertiliser, irrigation and pesticide had all become dearer, and production costs had climbed far above those of earlier years. Because potatoes had fetched good prices in the previous season, they were taking that risk with some hope.
The district's agriculture office expected prices to be good and, unless a major natural disaster struck, a good yield. The farmers interviewed for the report were less certain. They said that if the market did not pay a fair price, they would lose the capital they had put into the crop.
Three early varieties and the season's target
Early varieties known locally as Diamond, Asterix and Cardinal had been planted across the district, according to the report, which said these varieties become ready for sale 55 to 60 days after planting. The Department of Agricultural Extension (DAE) had set a target of 27,500 hectares of potatoes for Thakurgaon in the 2024-25 season, and by the time of the report early potatoes had been planted on 2,700 hectares.
Two of the three varieties have been grown in Bangladesh for decades. Banglapedia, the national encyclopaedia, lists Cardinal and Diamant, the variety farmers call Diamond, among the high-yielding varieties brought from the Netherlands. It gives Cardinal a yield of 20 to 25 tonnes a hectare and describes Diamant as disease resistant, with 18 to 24 tonnes a hectare. According to Banglapedia, about 16 high-yielding varieties were selected in the 1970s, ten were later dropped and about ten have been released for cultivation; other exotic varieties grown in the country include Patronis, Alpha, Archa, Multa, Ukama, Hira, Maurin, Origo and Alisa, alongside some 27 local varieties such as Sheel Bilatee of Rangpur, Lal Sheel of Bogura and Lal Pakri of Dinajpur, Bogura and Sirajganj.
Asterix is a more recent arrival. A field trial at Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman Agricultural University in Gazipur, run from November 2013 to February 2014 and published in the Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Research in 2018, compared Asterix, Cardinal, Diamant and Granola harvested 90 days after planting. Asterix gave the highest yield, 31.46 tonnes a hectare, followed by Diamant at 29.91 tonnes and Cardinal at 27.27 tonnes, while Granola gave 24.82 tonnes. Between 60 and 70 days after planting, Cardinal had the highest tuber bulking rate and Asterix the highest tuber growth rate, the researchers found.
Planting early is an old habit in Thakurgaon. In November 2014 The Daily Star reported that growers in Sadar and other upazilas were already harvesting early varieties and selling them at Tk 30 to 35 a kilogram in local markets, after Tk 40 to 45 when the new potatoes first appeared a week earlier. That season the DAE had set a district target of 21,200 hectares, and early varieties covered about 8,480 hectares across the five upazilas. Farmers then planted the early crop after harvesting short-duration aman varieties such as Bina-7, or after short-term vegetables, and traders came from Dhaka, Chattogram and other districts to buy directly from the fields. Officials and farmers at the time credited favourable weather and cheap fertiliser and seed for the good returns, a contrast with the costs farmers described ten years later.

Seed: dearer, and too little from the government
Farmers were buying potato seed from outside sources at Tk 80 to 85 a kilogram, the report said, Tk 25 to 30 more than a year earlier and more than double the price of the season before that. In the 2023-24 season they had been able to buy seed at Tk 50 to 60 a kilogram, and in the season before at Tk 30 to 35.
Government seed for the 2024-25 season had been priced at Tk 57 to Tk 66 a kilogram depending on the variety, but there was not enough of it to meet demand. Sources quoted in the report said the Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation (BADC) produces 20 to 25 per cent of the country's potato seed; the rest is kept by farmers at home or produced by private companies and non-governmental organisations. With too little government seed available, farmers said, they were forced to buy at higher prices.
BADC is the state corporation that imports seed potatoes and distributes certified seed through contract growers and its local offices, according to Banglapedia. The research side lies with the Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute (BARI), whose Tuber Crops Research Centre has collected new varieties from the International Potato Center in Peru and other sources and helped develop several high-yielding varieties. BARI also runs a seed farm at Debiganj in Panchagarh, the district bordering Thakurgaon to the north, where its breeders' potato seed production centre produces seed potatoes.
The shortage was not confined to Thakurgaon. On 4 November 2024 the daily Ittefaq reported a seed shortage at the start of planting in BADC's Rangpur region, which covers Rangpur, Nilphamari, Lalmonirhat, Gaibandha and Kurigram districts. BADC's prices there were Tk 66 a kilogram for A-grade Asterix seed, Tk 64 for A-grade seed of other varieties, Tk 63 for B grade and Tk 60 for large tubers. The corporation's allocation for the five districts that season was 2,797.32 tonnes: 2,261.6 tonnes for its registered dealers, 282.56 tonnes for early planting and 252.872 tonnes for farmers and seed-producing firms, shared among 818 registered dealers. Over six years, the paper reported, the potato area in those districts had grown by about 9,202 hectares while BADC's seed allocation had fallen by about 1,428.759 tonnes. BADC's regional office said allocations were decided at its Dhaka office and that it had applied for about 3,200 tonnes; a farmers' cooperative leader in Pirganj, Rangpur, said an acre needs about 800 kilograms of seed.
Seed had already become dearer a year earlier. In November 2023 Daily Star Bangla reported that BADC's Asterix seed had risen from Tk 29 a kilogram the year before to Tk 40, and that BADC had begun selling seed of the Rumana and Pakri varieties for the first time, Pakri at Tk 52 a kilogram. A BADC seed production official in Bogura said then that government seed prices had risen somewhat because production costs had gone up, but that there was no shortage of seed.
Fertiliser: official prices and what farmers said they paid
The report set out the government prices for a bag of fertiliser at the dealer and farmer levels. Dealers receive triple super phosphate (TSP) and urea at Tk 1,250 a bag, against a farmer price of Tk 1,350; diammonium phosphate (DAP) at Tk 950, against Tk 1,050; and muriate of potash (MOP) at Tk 900, against Tk 1,000. The report described the higher figure as the price at which dealers sell, which reads as if dealers were overcharging; in fact both are official prices.
They come from the Ministry of Agriculture's order of April 2023, which took effect on 10 April 2023 and raised the price of each of the four fertilisers by Tk 5 a kilogram at both levels. Under that order urea and TSP cost Tk 25 a kilogram for dealers and Tk 27 for farmers, DAP Tk 19 and Tk 21, and MOP Tk 18 and Tk 20. The bag prices in the report match these rates for a 50-kilogram bag.
What farmers said they actually paid was higher. According to the report, they were paying Tk 1,700 a bag for Tunisian TSP and Tk 2,200 for locally made TSP, Tk 1,100 for Moroccan DAP and Tk 1,500 for local DAP, and Tk 1,200 for Canadian MOP, while Russian MOP was available at the government price. Several farmers told the paper that no dealer gave receipts, and that dealers would not sell fertiliser to anyone who asked for one. In all, farmers said, the price of a bag had risen by up to Tk 200. The report carried no response from dealers.
When the government raised the prices in April 2023, its order cited the rise in fertiliser prices on the world market. bdnews24.com reported at the time that international prices were about Tk 48 a kilogram for urea, Tk 70 for DAP, Tk 50 for TSP and Tk 60 for MOP, so that even after the increase the government was paying a subsidy of Tk 21 a kilogram on urea, Tk 49 on DAP, Tk 23 on TSP and Tk 40 on MOP. Spending on fertiliser subsidy had grown from Tk 7,420 crore in fiscal 2020-21 to Tk 28,000 crore in 2021-22, and about Tk 46,000 crore was expected in 2022-23. The ministry put the country's need for fiscal 2023-24 at 6,842,500 tonnes of 11 kinds of fertiliser, including 2.7 million tonnes of urea, 1.6 million tonnes of DAP, 900,000 tonnes of MOP and 750,000 tonnes of TSP. The previous increase, of Tk 6 a kilogram on urea alone, had come on 1 August 2022.

Production costs as farmers described them
Extra irrigation and pesticide had pushed costs to what the report called abnormal levels. Growing potatoes on a bigha of land, which used to cost Tk 40,000, now cost Tk 70,000. Farmers said that if they could buy seed, fertiliser and pesticide at government rates, their costs could come down somewhat.
Tarikul, a farmer of Nargun union, said: "Last year the cost doubled as potato seed, fertiliser and pesticide prices rose. This year costs have gone up even more. If we don't get prices like last time, we will be ruined in the field."
Sohel Rana of Akcha union said: "Just a year before last, potatoes on 50 decimals cost Tk 30,000-40,000. Last year that rose to Tk 50,000-55,000, and this year the same land costs Tk 70,000. I grow potatoes every year and have done so again, but I am very worried about the market."
Growers elsewhere in the north had described the same pressure a year earlier. In the Daily Star Bangla report of November 2023, farmers in northern Bangladesh said the cost of growing potatoes had nearly doubled, blaming dearer fertiliser, pesticide, irrigation and seed, and fuel prices that had raised the cost of ploughing and pumping. A farmer in Shibganj upazila of Bogura said two bighas of potatoes were costing him Tk 55,000, against Tk 30,000 for the same land the year before; land preparation had gone from Tk 200 to Tk 400 a bigha and a single irrigation from Tk 200 to Tk 300 a bigha. Fertiliser had risen by Tk 300 to 400 a sack and government seed by more than Tk 10 a kilogram, that report said, and a farmer in Kalai upazila of Joypurhat expected the price of new potatoes to rise along with the cost.
Why farmers took the risk
Farmers told Jagonews24 they were willing to bear the higher costs because potato prices had been good over the past two seasons. Reports from that period show how high those prices were.
In September 2023 potatoes were selling at Tk 42 to 45 a kilogram in Dhaka, 57 per cent more than a year earlier according to the Trading Corporation of Bangladesh (TCB), The Daily Star reported. Official estimates then put the 2023 crop at a record: 1.04 crore (10.4 million) tonnes by the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) and 1.12 crore tonnes by the DAE, against annual demand of about 90 lakh (9 million) tonnes. The Bangladesh Cold Storage Association disputed those numbers, putting output at no more than 85 lakh tonnes; the DAE's director general said that claim was not true, and the BBS said it follows the method of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations every year.
Prices stayed high into the next harvest. In late December 2023 Prothom Alo reported potatoes at Tk 70 to 80 a kilogram in Dhaka's Malibagh, Mogbazar and Rampura markets, up Tk 10 within a week. Normally, the paper explained, cold-stored potatoes run out in early December, new potatoes arrive and prices fall by mid-December; that year they had not, and the cold storage association's president said the early potato yield had fallen.
In April 2024, with the 2023-24 crop harvested, Prothom Alo reported that potatoes cost more than coarse rice in Dhaka: about Tk 50 a kilogram at the cheapest and Tk 55 to 60 in some markets, against Tk 50 to 52 for coarse rice according to TCB. A year earlier, TCB data showed, potatoes had sold at Tk 24 to 30. The cold storage association said farmers had sold at higher prices from the start of the season and that the extra production needed to make up the previous year's shortfall had not come.
With prices still high, the National Board of Revenue (NBR) cut the customs duty on imported potatoes from 25 to 15 per cent and withdrew the 3 per cent regulatory duty on 5 September 2024, Prothom Alo reported, citing UNB. The cut was temporary, to last until 30 November 2024; the NBR said the aim was to ease imports and increase supply, and that incentives for local farmers would continue. The paper noted that lower import duties could discourage local growers, which was why the cut was limited in time.
High prices are not guaranteed, and Thakurgaon growers have known bad years. In June 2022, after a large harvest, growers and traders protested in the district town over cold storage rent. The DAE in Thakurgaon put that season's production at 740,584 tonnes from 27,677 hectares, against a target of 679,798 tonnes on 28,515 hectares, while the district's 16 cold storages could hold 136,550 tonnes at a time, The Daily Star reported. Growers then said their cost of producing and storing potatoes came to Tk 18 a kilogram, while potatoes were selling at Tk 18 to 19 a kilogram at the cold storage gates. A grower from Nargun village was among those who complained that rents in Thakurgaon were higher than in Manikganj and Munshiganj.
What the agriculture office said
The agriculture office, however, said potatoes were likely to fetch good prices, and the agriculture department expected a good yield in the 2024-25 season unless there was a major natural disaster.
Agriculturist Mst Nazma Akter, acting deputy director of the Department of Agricultural Extension in Thakurgaon, said: "We regularly go to the field and advise potato farmers. Thakurgaon's soil and climate are well suited to potatoes. But production costs are higher this time. I hope farmers will be able to recover their costs through fair market prices."
Thakurgaon, a farming district on the border
Thakurgaon is a district of Rangpur division covering 1,781.74 square kilometres, according to Banglapedia. Panchagarh district lies to its north, Panchagarh and Dinajpur to its east, and the Indian state of West Bengal to its south and west. Its five upazilas are Thakurgaon Sadar, the largest, Pirganj, Ranisankail, Baliadangi and Haripur, the smallest. The Tangon, Nagar, Kulik, Tirnai and Pathari rivers run through it. Thakurgaon became a subdivision of Dinajpur in 1860 and a district in 1984; it has three municipalities and 51 unions. The 2011 census counted 1,390,042 people, and agriculture was the main source of income for 76.74 per cent of them.
The two farmers quoted in the report come from Akcha and Nargun, two of the 19 unions of Thakurgaon Sadar upazila. Banglapedia lists the upazila's main crops as paddy, wheat, potato, sugarcane, pulses, mustard and vegetables, and its main exports as rice, pulses, potato, mango, jackfruit, litchi, watermelon, sugar and vegetables; cold storages are among its industries. Wheat is the district's other big winter crop: Prothom Alo described Thakurgaon in December 2022 as the country's top wheat-producing district, with a wheat target of 44,699 hectares that season.
How the crop is grown
In Bangladesh potatoes are a winter crop grown in every district, and Banglapedia gives the first fortnight of November as the right planting time, adding that some farmers in the north-west plant in October for an early harvest, as Thakurgaon's growers do. The crop needs sunny, well-fertilised land with enough soil moisture. Seed tubers are planted by hand, usually in rows 45 to 60 centimetres apart; when they are planted shallow, about 5 centimetres deep, soil is ridged over the rows to protect the tubers from light and pests. Water hyacinth or straw is used as mulch to keep in moisture and hold back weeds. Most varieties are harvested by hand in February and March, ideally when the leaves turn yellow and brown. The amounts of fertiliser and pesticide depend on the soil and the variety, and farmers should take them from the upazila agriculture office.
Most small farmers store potatoes at home by traditional methods, which leads to considerable losses from drying out, pests and disease, Banglapedia notes; this is why cold storage rent and capacity matter so much in a district like Thakurgaon. In Bangladesh the potato is eaten mainly as a vegetable, most often in curries with fish, meat or eggs, and also boiled, fried, mashed and in snacks such as singara, chops and chips.
The crop came to the subcontinent long ago. Banglapedia says Portuguese sailors are assumed to have brought it to India early in the 17th century; cultivation began around Calcutta, spread to Cherrapunji, and was encouraged by Warren Hastings, governor from 1772 to 1785. In Bangladesh, potatoes covered 136,332 hectares in 1997-98, and national production rose from about 4.66 million tonnes in 2005-06 to 8.2 million tonnes in 2007-08, the encyclopaedia records.

Photo: কুউ পুলক / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0). The top picture shows a potato field in Munshiganj, as background; it is not Thakurgaon.
Sources: Jagonews24 (9 November 2024), Ittefaq (4 November 2024), Prothom Alo (5 September 2024, English edition; 14 April 2024; 29 December 2023, English edition; 8 December 2022), Daily Star Bangla (9 November 2023; 11 April 2023), The Daily Star (11 September 2023; 7 June 2022; 30 November 2014), bdnews24.com (11 April 2023), Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Research (2018), Banglapedia (Potato; Thakurgaon District; Thakurgaon Sadar Upazila)





Comments
(0)