How much milk a cow gives, and how rich that milk is, depends first on her breed and then on how she is fed, milked, housed and bred. A farming guide that Jagonews24 published on 22 August 2017 set out these factors for Bangladeshi cattle keepers: local cows give rich milk but little of it, foreign breeds give more; a balanced ration matters more than a large one; milking two or three times a day can raise the yield; a cow needs care in pregnancy and a rest from milking before she calves; hot, humid weather cuts production; and a cow should be served again within 60 to 90 days of calving and allowed to drink as much water as she wants.
This report sets out that advice as the guide gave it, checks each point against the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), Banglapedia and research by the Bangladesh Livestock Research Institute (BLRI), Bangladesh Agricultural University and other scientists published before the guide appeared, and adds the background a farmer or student needs to use it. Where a figure in the original could not be confirmed, it has been left out. Rations and any medicine for a particular cow are a matter for the upazila livestock officer or a veterinarian.
Milk in Bangladesh: demand, supply and the family cow
Milk is a large part of the livestock economy that the Department of Livestock Services (DLS) oversees. DLS figures put national milk production at 72.75 lakh tonnes in the 2015-16 fiscal year, up from 69.70 lakh tonnes in 2014-15 and 22.90 lakh tonnes in 2008-09. The department measures demand against a norm of 250 millilitres of milk per person per day. Banglapedia notes that total milk production is much lower than national demand, and that a considerable quantity of milk powder is therefore imported.
The cattle that produce this milk are mostly kept in small numbers. DLS counted 237.85 lakh cattle and 14.71 lakh buffaloes in the country in 2015-16. Banglapedia describes most of these cattle as non-descript indigenous zebu (humped) animals used for several purposes at once: milk, meat, draught power, and dung for manure and fuel. Only about 16.01 percent of households keep milch cows, it says, and most of them own only one; keeping more than two milch cows is very rare. In recent years, Banglapedia adds, a number of small commercial dairy farms have been set up, particularly in urban and peri-urban areas.
A survey of 1,440 dairy farms in Mymensingh, Khulna-Satkhira, Sirajganj-Pabna and Chittagong, published in Tropical Animal Health and Production in 2006 by a team led by M. Shamsuddin of Bangladesh Agricultural University, shows what is at stake for such farmers. Average milk production per cow ranged from 3.5 to 7.2 litres a day depending on the area, feed cost took between 52.5 and 92.1 percent of income from milk, and producing 100 litres of milk cost between 18.9 and 35.1 US dollars. The cost of production rose as daily milk per cow fell, so the authors concluded that management improvements aimed at more milk per cow per day, longer lactations, an earlier age at first calving and a shorter interval between calves could raise farm income substantially.
Milk itself is mostly water. Banglapedia gives the average composition of cow's milk as 87.6 percent water, 3.7 percent fat, 3.2 percent protein, 4.8 percent lactose and 0.72 percent ash, and describes whole milk as an excellent source of calcium, phosphorus, riboflavin, protein and vitamin A.
Breed: local cows give richer milk, crossbreds give more
The guide began with breed: milk from local cows is richer in butterfat, but local cows produce little milk, while foreign breeds give more. Research supports both halves of that statement. Banglapedia puts the average yield of Bangladesh's indigenous cattle at about 206 kilograms per lactation. Among the better local types, a Pabna cow can produce 3 to 5 litres of milk a day and a Red Chittagong cow about 2 litres. Banglapedia lists the improved indigenous types as Pabna Cattle, Red Chittagong, Munshiganj Cattle and North Bengal Grey Cattle, and notes that no specific cattle breed has yet been established in the country.
Since the 1960s, Banglapedia says, farmers have kept pure foreign breeds, crossbreds and local cattle, and efforts to raise the milk of local cattle by crossing them with breeds such as Holstein-Friesian, Jersey, Sahiwal, Haryana and Sindhi have been made several times. The crossbreds it lists, Sahiwal-Pabna, Friesian-Pabna, Sahiwal-local and Friesian crosses, produce 1,240, 1,460, 728 and 1,800 litres per lactation respectively. The trade-off is that pure and crossbred cattle have higher nutritional needs, adapt less well and are more susceptible to parasites and disease, while local cattle resist disease, tolerate heat and make good use of low-quality roughage. Banglapedia adds that crossbred cows in Bangladesh often fail to reach their potential because of harsh conditions, a lack of green fodder, unskilled management and little knowledge of health care.
On milk quality, a study by scientists of BLRI at Savar, Bangladesh Agricultural University and the Norwegian University of Life Sciences, published in the Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences in June 2014, compared pooled milk from Holstein cross, indigenous and Red Chittagong cows and from buffaloes. Fat content was 43.40 grams per kilogram in indigenous cattle milk and 42.33 grams in Red Chittagong milk, against 37.13 grams in Holstein cross milk; buffalo milk was richest at 58.40 grams. The indigenous and Red Chittagong milk also contained more protein, casein, lactose and minerals. Yet at the time of sampling the Holstein cross cows were giving 2.5 to 8.5 litres a day, compared with 2.5 to 5.8 litres for the indigenous cows and 1.3 to 5.0 litres for the Red Chittagong cows.
BLRI itself, set up at Savar in 1984 as an autonomous institute, works on these questions. Banglapedia records that it runs a selective breeding programme on Pabna cattle among other animals, develops methods of fodder and feed production and preservation, and studies the use of agricultural by-products as feed. It has regional stations at Baghabari in Sirajganj and Naikhongchhari in Bandarban.
Feed: a balanced ration with enough fibre
Feed, the guide said, has an important effect on both the amount and quality of milk. A cow that is fed more gives more milk, but the ration must be balanced, because what the cow eats is passed into her milk in another form and can raise or lower the butterfat. The guide warned that too much concentrate, pelleted feed, overly succulent feed or finely ground straw can lower the butterfat in milk, and that when the fat falls the ration should be changed back to a balanced one. Minerals and vitamins in milk can be raised through feed, and a cow on an unbalanced diet gives less milk with little protein and carbohydrate in it.
Dairy science explains the warning about concentrate and finely ground straw. Researchers at Penn State University, writing in the Journal of Dairy Science in 2015, described diet-induced milk fat depression as caused by highly fermentable diets and diets high in unsaturated fatty acids; it lowers both the fat concentration and the fat yield of milk. In their trial they brought on the condition with a low-fibre ration and then corrected it by restoring fibre and lowering unsaturated fat, after which milk fat recovered progressively. A review by scientists at Clemson and Penn State universities in 2014 added that fat intake by dairy cattle must be restricted to prevent changes in the rumen's microbes that can reduce milk yield.
In Bangladesh the basic feeds are the by-products of crop farming. Banglapedia lists them as crop residues such as rice and wheat straw, sugarcane tops and bagasse; agro-industrial by-products such as molasses and oil cakes; milling by-products such as brans; green roughage from roadside and embankment grasses, jackfruit and mango leaves, ipil-ipil and water plants; and cultivated fodder, including Napier, Para and German grasses and seasonal crops such as maize, cowpea, khesari and oats. Cultivated fodder is scarce: Banglapedia gives about 6,312 hectares under fodder crops, producing only about 47,000 tonnes, and says only about 190,000 tonnes of grain is available for livestock, about 15.7 percent of the concentrate feed needed. BLRI developed a urea-molasses-straw feeding technology to make better use of straw.
The BLRI milk study of 2014 shows how its own animals were fed. The Holstein cross cows received German, Napier, oat and para grass, plus about 2.75 kilograms of a concentrate mixture of wheat bran, broken maize, khesari, soybean, dicalcium phosphate and salt per head per day for the first 3 litres of milk, and an extra 0.5 kilogram of that mixture for every additional litre. The indigenous and Red Chittagong cows were given German and Napier grass and grazed roadside grass. These are the rations of one research farm, not a recipe for every cow: a cow's needs depend on her weight, her yield and the feeds at hand, and the upazila livestock officer can help a farmer work out a ration.
Green grass matters for health as well as yield. A study of 212 smallholder dairy farms in the Sadar upazilas of Rangpur, Mymensingh and Satkhira, carried out in 2011 by veterinary scientists at Bangladesh Agricultural University and published in 2013, found that cows given no grass were more likely to have subclinical mastitis, as were cows in poor body condition.

Milking: frequency, intervals and a calm routine
The guide said that milking, including the stage of lactation, the time and method of milking and the different teats, affects the amount and quality of milk; that the yield and composition depend on the pressure of milk in the udder; and that milking the same cow at short intervals gives milk with more butterfat, which is why evening milk is richer than morning milk. It advised milking two or three times in 24 hours to raise the yield.
The FAO manual Milking, milk production hygiene and udder health (Animal Production and Health Paper 78, 1989) confirms and explains these points. Milk is secreted continuously, at a usually constant rate for at least 12 hours, so the pressure inside the udder rises steadily between milkings. When milking begins, a nerve and hormone reflex called milk ejection, or let-down, makes the small milk sacs and ducts contract and push the milk down. Even so, 10 to 20 percent of the milk stays in the udder as residual milk, which has a much higher fat content than the rest. With unequal milking intervals, more of this rich residual milk carries over from the long night-time interval to the shorter daytime one, which accounts for the higher fat content of afternoon milk.
On timing, the FAO manual says yields, particularly from higher-yielding cows, are usually greatest when cows are milked at 12-hour intervals. Unequal intervals up to 16 and 8 hours have only a small effect, which can be reduced by milking the highest yielders first in the morning and last in the afternoon. On frequency, milking three times a day instead of twice raises milk yields by an average of 10 to 15 percent, with the largest increases in heifers, and does not change the milk's fat or solids-not-fat. The manual cautions that in developed dairying areas up to 10 percent extra yield was needed to cover the extra cost of a third milking, and that the full benefit comes from milking three times throughout the lactation.
The FAO manual adds that, whatever the timing, the average fat content of milk over a period stays the same: fat left in the udder at one milking is not lost but comes out at the next. What does lose milk is a poor routine. Its advice for hand milking and for a stress-free routine is:
- Keep to a regular, repeated routine; cows are creatures of habit, and the let-down reflex is stimulated by familiar signals such as feeding and udder preparation.
- Milk soon after let-down: the pressure of milk inside the udder peaks one to two minutes after milk ejection, and the effect fades within a few minutes.
- Avoid anything that frightens or upsets the cow; fear releases adrenalin, which holds back milk ejection and leaves more milk in the udder.
- Milk with clean, dry hands, using the full hand, and avoid stripping with the finger and thumb at the end of milking.
- Milk the rear quarters first, as they contain most milk, and keep the bucket covered to reduce contamination from dust and udder hairs.
The guide had also given a share of milk for the front and rear teats; those figures could not be confirmed and have been left out. The FAO manual's finding is simply that the rear quarters contain most of the milk.
A healthy udder and mastitis
The guide stressed that the teats and udder must be kept healthy and that faulty milking lowers both the amount and the quality of milk. The FAO manual describes mastitis, an inflammation of the udder, as common in dairy herds and a cause of important economic losses. It cannot be eradicated, the manual says, but it can be kept at low levels by good management. Mastitis reduces milk yields, and milk that is abnormal or contaminated with antibiotics cannot be sold. Many infections are subclinical, showing no visible sign in the milk or the udder, while some cause raised body temperature and loss of appetite and, without treatment, can kill the cow.
Subclinical mastitis is common in Bangladesh. In the 2011 study of 212 smallholder farms in Rangpur, Mymensingh and Satkhira, 20.2 percent of the cows examined had it. The risk factors that remained in the final analysis were a history of clinical mastitis, a pendulous udder, no grass feeding and a body condition score of 2.5 or less; the authors suggested particular emphasis on grass feeding and body condition, because those can be improved.
The FAO manual's measures for control centre on milking hygiene: clean equipment and hands, disinfecting the teats after milking, and careful attention at drying off and calving, when new infections are common. A cow whose milk looks abnormal, or who has a fever or goes off her feed, needs a veterinarian; drugs, doses and the time milk must be withheld after treatment should come from the upazila livestock officer or a registered veterinarian, not from a shop.
Pregnancy, the dry period and calving
Good health at calving, the guide said, is very important for the expected yield. To get more milk, a cow needs proper care and a balanced diet during pregnancy, and milking must be stopped two months before calving.
That two-month rest, known as the dry period, is standard advice backed by research. A systematic review by Wageningen University scientists, published in The Veterinary Journal in 2013, said a dry period of six to eight weeks is generally thought to maximise milk production in the next lactation. Its meta-analysis found that shortening or omitting the dry period reduces milk production and raises milk protein percentage in the next lactation, without changing milk fat percentage; the claimed gains in health and fertility from a shorter dry period were marginal.
Heat during this period also matters. A review of heat stress in dairy animals, published in Veterinary World in March 2016 by scientists of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research's National Dairy Research Institute and other institutes, reported that heat stress in the dry period, the last two months of gestation, reduced the multiplication of udder cells and so lowered milk yield in the following lactation. The FAO manual notes that new udder infections are most common at the start of the dry period and around calving, which is why udder hygiene matters most then.

Heat, season and housing
The guide said management and housing are largely responsible for rises and falls in milk, and that a cow's surroundings should be comfortable. It called harsh weather bad for production: winter is comfortable for milking cows, and both yield and butterfat rise then, while summer, the monsoon and humid weather reduce yield and quality. Keeping cows cool in the hot season, it said, prevents the loss.
The 2016 Veterinary World review sets out why. The thermoneutral zone of dairy animals, the range of temperature in which they keep a normal body temperature of 38.4 to 39.1 degrees Celsius without extra effort, is 16 to 25 degrees Celsius. In high air temperature and humidity, heat production inside the body outstrips its loss to the surroundings, and the animal breathes faster, its heart rate and body temperature rise, and it eats less. Lower feed intake is the main reason milk falls, and the review cites drops in milk production of up to 50 percent. Dairy breeds are more sensitive to heat than meat breeds, and higher-producing cows are more susceptible because they make more metabolic heat. The review also found that milk fat and protein decline when the temperature-humidity index goes beyond 72, and that hot, humid conditions are linked with more mastitis.
The review's practical measures are the ones the guide pointed to: change the cow's surroundings. It lists housing or shade along with feed and drinking water, and evaporative cooling with fog, mist or sprinkling together with natural or fan-driven air movement. For animals outdoors, shade is one of the simplest and cheapest measures, and trees are very effective because their leaves also cool the air as moisture evaporates. Where there is no natural shade, an artificial roof can be built, and the review considers a white galvanised or aluminium roof best. Cows given access to sprinklers, with or without fans, produced more milk, bred better and converted feed to milk more efficiently.
Banglapedia notes that this is one area where local cattle have an advantage: they are heat tolerant, while pure and crossbred cattle adapt less well, which makes cool, airy housing and shade especially important for crossbred cows.

Breeding again after calving
The guide advised serving a cow within 60 to 90 days of calving. Its reasoning about calving intervals was unclear, so this report gives the research instead. Banglapedia says that in a milked cow, activity of the ovaries normally returns within 30 days of calving. It lists the causes of anoestrus, when a cow shows no heat at all, as seasonal changes, poor nutrition, lactation, stress and age: low energy in the diet and shortages of minerals and vitamins can stop heat, and in Bangladesh, it says, many cows that are also used for draught show signs of it.
In practice Bangladeshi cows are served much later than the guide's window. A study of 6,101 first inseminations on smallholder farms in four regions in 2004-05, published in Reproduction in Domestic Animals in 2013 by scientists at Bangladesh Agricultural University, found that the average interval from calving to first service was 153.4 days. The conception rate at first insemination averaged 50.7 percent, and body condition and the signs used to detect heat had the greatest effect on it; inseminations based on mounting activity gave a conception rate of 53.6 percent. The authors concluded that fertility could be improved by training farmers in nutrition and reproductive management. A Rajshahi University study of 313 crossbred cows in greater Rajshahi, published in 2007, recorded an average calving interval of 438 days and an average post-partum heat period of 139 days.
A modelling study from Utrecht University, published in the Journal of Dairy Science in 2011, looked at the economics of the waiting period before first insemination for Dutch dairy cows. It found that the best waiting period for 90 percent of cows was less than 10 weeks, and that on average every waiting period longer than six weeks caused economic losses. The 2006 smallholder survey reached a similar conclusion for Bangladesh: shortening the interval between calves was one of the improvements that could raise farm income. A farmer who is unsure whether a cow is in heat, or whose cow has not come into heat after calving, can seek help from the upazila livestock office or an artificial insemination technician.
Water
Finally, the guide said that milk is about 87 percent water, so letting a cow drink as much water as she wants increases milk production. Banglapedia's figure for the water in cow's milk, 87.6 percent, confirms the first part. The guide also gave a figure for the water content of a cow's body, which could not be confirmed and has been left out.
How much a cow drinks depends on how much she produces and on the weather. A study by scientists at the University of California, Davis and the University of Nebraska, published in the Journal of Dairy Science in 2016, built models of the drinking water intake of dairy cows from published data. Water intake rose with the amount of dry feed a cow ate, the dry matter and protein content of her ration, the sodium and potassium in her diet and the daily air temperature, and, in a model without feed intake, with her milk yield and days in milk. In other words, a cow in full milk on a hot day needs much more water than a dry cow in winter, which is why clean water within easy reach at all times matters. The 2016 heat stress review lists drinking water alongside shade and feed among the first measures against heat.
Photo: Reaid Hossain / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Sources: Jagonews24, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO, Animal Production and Health Paper 78), Department of Livestock Services (DLS), Banglapedia, Asian-Australasian Journal of Animal Sciences (Islam and colleagues, 2014), Veterinary World (Das and colleagues, 2016), The Veterinary Journal (van Knegsel and colleagues, 2013), Journal of Dairy Science (Rico and colleagues, 2015; Appuhamy and colleagues, 2016; Inchaisri and colleagues, 2011), Veterinary Clinics of North America: Food Animal Practice (Jenkins and Harvatine, 2014), Tropical Animal Health and Production (Shamsuddin and colleagues, 2006; Sarker and colleagues, 2013), Reproduction in Domestic Animals (Siddiqui and colleagues, 2013), Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences (Sarder and colleagues, 2007)





Comments
(0)