A legal notice was sent in April 2024 to Dhaka South City Corporation (DSCC) and other authorities asking them not to hold a qurbani cattle market in Aftabnagar, a residential area in the east of the capital, ahead of Eid-ul-Azha. The notice called the leasing process that the DSCC had announced on 4 April 2024 unlawful and asked for it to be suspended. Lawyer Md Yunus Ali Akand sent the notice by post, and on Monday, 15 April 2024, he confirmed the matter to the news portal Jagonews24 himself.
The notice set a deadline of 72 hours. According to its text, if the authorities did not take steps on the cattle market within 72 hours of receiving it, legal action would follow in the form of a writ petition to the High Court. The Jagonews24 report of 15 April 2024 carried no response from the DSCC or from any of the other authorities named in the notice.
Who the notice was sent to
The notice named five office holders as respondents: the secretary of the Ministry of Local Government, the mayor of Dhaka South City Corporation, the city corporation's secretary (chief estate officer), the chairman of Rajdhani Unnayan Kartripakkha (RAJUK) and the deputy commissioner (DC) of Dhaka.
Each of these offices has a part in how open land in the capital is used. The Local Government Division of the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Co-operatives oversees the city corporations, and the DSCC's own lease notice was issued on the ministry's behalf. The mayor heads the city corporation, and its estate department handles the leasing of the corporation's markets and property. RAJUK is the capital's planning and development authority, and the deputy commissioner heads the district administration of Dhaka.
According to Banglapedia, RAJUK is a statutory body under the Ministry of Housing and Public Works that is responsible for initiating and carrying out the development plans of the Dhaka metropolitan city. It began as the Dhaka Improvement Trust (DIT), founded in 1956 under the Town Improvement Act 1953, and became Rajdhani Unnayan Kartripakkha (Capital City Development Authority) under the Town Improvement (Amendment) Act 1987. It is run by a board made up of a chairman and not more than five members, all appointed by the government, and its work includes approving building designs, planning residential and commercial areas and providing open spaces, parks and playgrounds.
The 4 April lease notice and the north-south question
The legal notice was a response to a tender issued on 4 April 2024. On that day, on behalf of the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Co-operatives (Local Government Division), the DSCC's estate department announced a tender through a lease notice signed by the corporation's chief estate officer, Kaiser Mohammad Farabi. The tender said that a qurbani cattle market would be held for five days, including the day of Eid-ul-Azha.
The legal notice asked for two things about that tender. It sought the suspension of the 4 April notice, and it sought a declaration that it was illegal for the south city corporation to publish such a notice for a place that, the sender argued, belonged to the north city corporation. In other words, the notice challenged both the holding of a market in a residential area and the DSCC's authority to lease that particular site.
The question of which corporation covers Aftabnagar had come up a year earlier. In 2023 the lease for the Aftabnagar market was offered by Dhaka North City Corporation (DNCC), not the DSCC. The Dhaka Tribune reported on 11 May 2023 that the DNCC had invited tenders on 2 May 2023 for eight animal markets, one of them on the open space from blocks B to H in Aftabnagar of Badda. A Dhaka Tribune report of 14 June 2023 said that the 2023 lease notice, signed by the DNCC's chief property officer on behalf of the Ministry of Local Government, called for market leases at seven places of the DNCC, including vacant spaces from Block B to H of Eastern Housing Aftab City and part of Badda union council.
What the notice says about the residential area
The legal notice set out the harm that, according to its sender, the cattle market does to the neighbourhood. It said that holding a cattle and goat market was seriously harming the living environment of the residential area, and that various kinds of waste from cattle and goats badly polluted the area.
The notice also said that the main road and Jahirul Islam City (Aftabnagar) were heavily damaged by the market. As a result, according to the notice, the main road was full of potholes all year round, and residents of Jahirul Islam City faced great difficulty in getting about.
These are the claims of the notice. The Jagonews24 report did not carry an assessment of them by the city corporation or by any other authority, and no official measurement of the waste or the road damage at Aftabnagar was published with the report.
Aftabnagar and Jahurul Islam City
Aftabnagar is a residential area in Badda, in the east of Dhaka. Its formal name in the legal notice, Jahirul Islam City, refers to the project of Eastern Housing, and the 2023 lease notice described the site as Eastern Housing Aftab City. The open land that was offered for the cattle market lies in the area's lettered blocks: the 2023 tender listed the open space from blocks B to H.
The housing project carries the name of Jahurul Islam (1928-1995), a businessman whose life is recorded in Banglapedia. Born on 1 August 1928 in Bhagalpur village of Bajitpur in Kishoreganj district, he started work in 1948 as a low-grade employee of the then C and B (Communications and Buildings) department, left the job to set up a small contracting firm, and later founded Bengal Development Corporation, which grew into a large construction house. Banglapedia lists among the buildings associated with him the Bangladesh Bank, the High Court and Supreme Court buildings, Ganabhaban and Nagar Bhaban.
Banglapedia also records that he foresaw a housing shortage in fast-growing Dhaka and set up Eastern Housing Ltd in 1965, which it describes as the first real estate organisation in the country. Aftabnagar is one of that company's housing projects, which is why the area is also known by his name.

The dispute over the Aftabnagar market in 2023
The 2024 notice was not the first legal challenge to a cattle market in Aftabnagar. In 2023 the same lawyer went to the High Court over the DNCC's plan to hold a makeshift market there.
According to the Dhaka Tribune of 14 June 2023, Advocate Yunus Ali Akand filed a writ petition in the public interest on 15 May 2023, seeking a directive not to set up a makeshift cattle market in Aftabnagar and demanding protection of the environment. That writ named as respondents the secretary of the Ministry of Local Government, Rural Development and Co-operatives, the Dhaka North City Corporation, the DNCC's chief land officer, the chairman of RAJUK, Eastern Housing and the Dhaka deputy commissioner.
A High Court bench then halted the decision to set up the market and issued a rule. The Daily Star's Bengali edition reported that the High Court had suspended the DNCC's decision on 18 May 2023 for eight weeks and questioned its legality in a rule, while the Dhaka Tribune described a one-week stay that was later extended by two months. The city corporation then applied to the Appellate Division against the order.
On Wednesday, 14 June 2023, a three-member bench of the Appellate Division stayed the High Court's order for four weeks. As a result, lawyers said, there was no legal obstacle to the DNCC holding the temporary market in Aftabnagar ahead of Eid-ul-Azha that year. The DNCC's lawyer told The Daily Star that the temporary cattle market would run on the empty land for the convenience of local people.
The 2024 legal notice repeated several elements of that case, including the environmental argument, the inclusion of RAJUK and the Dhaka deputy commissioner among the respondents and the warning of a writ petition, but this time it was addressed to the DSCC, which had published the lease notice for the site.
Two city corporations for one capital
Dhaka has had two city corporations since 2011. Banglapedia records that the former Dhaka City Corporation was dissolved under the Local Government (City Corporation) Amendment Act 2011, passed on 29 November 2011, and divided into Dhaka South City Corporation and Dhaka North City Corporation on 4 December 2011, with the gazette notification published on 1 February 2012. Under the Act, each corporation is a self-governing body, which gave Dhaka two mayors.
Banglapedia describes the functions given to the city corporation under the 1983 ordinance that created it as including public health, water supply and drainage, matters related to food and drink, animals, the building and upkeep of roads, street lighting, public safety and the upkeep of parks and gardens. The corporation was also given power to raise money through rates, tolls and fees and through rents and profits from its own properties, which is the basis on which markets are leased out.
The corporation itself grew out of a much smaller body. According to Banglapedia, the municipal government of Dhaka was established in 1864, when it covered roughly 20.72 square kilometres with a population of some 52,000, and was responsible for roads, conservancy, health services and education. The Dhaka Municipal Corporation Ordinance of 1983 made the city a corporation, and by then Dhaka had grown to a population of some 3,440,147 and an area of some 400 square kilometres.
Each corporation runs a permanent cattle market and adds temporary ones before Eid-ul-Azha. The Dhaka Tribune reported on 11 May 2023 that sacrificial animals would be sold at the permanent markets in Gabtoli in the north and Sarulia in the south, besides 16 makeshift markets, eight in each corporation. The DSCC had invited tenders on 27 April 2023 for its markets, at places including the vacant areas of the Postogola cremation ground, the Institute of Leather Technology ground, Meradia Bazar, the Little Friends Club, Kamalapur Stadium, Dania College in Jatrabari, the Dholaikhal truck stand, near Rahmatganj Club in Lalbagh and near Amulia Model Town. According to a DNCC source quoted in the same report, these makeshift markets were leased for a total of five days, including the day of Eid-ul-Azha, and the authorities could cancel any market from the list or add new ones.
The DNCC's 2023 list, according to the same report, covered Uttara Diabari sectors 16 and 18 near Bou Bazar, the Eastern Housing area in Mirpur Section 6, the open space from blocks B to H in Aftabnagar of Badda, the open space adjacent to Saidnagar in Vatara, the Bosila area of Mohammadpur, the playground of Dhaka Polytechnic Institute, the vacant area near Kaola Shiyaldanga and Rahman Nagar Residential Area in Ward 44. The DSCC invited one more tender on 30 April 2023 for an additional market on the vacant area adjacent to Amulia Model Town, and the leases were expected to be finalised by the middle of May.
The same report said the DNCC was again putting special emphasis on a digital market in 2023, in which farms approved by e-CAB and the Bangladesh Dairy Farmers Association (BDFA) could sell their animals online.

From a legal notice to a writ petition
A legal notice of this kind is a formal letter from a lawyer that sets out a complaint, states what the sender wants done and gives the authorities a time limit to act before the matter is taken to court. In this case the time limit was 72 hours, and the court action named in the notice was a writ petition.
Banglapedia explains that a writ petition is the means by which people seek remedies from the superior courts against arbitrary or illegal actions of any authority. Article 102 of the Constitution of Bangladesh gives the High Court Division power to grant remedies similar to the five classical writs (certiorari, habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition and quo warranto), even though the Constitution does not name them.
Under sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) of sub-article (2) of Article 102, the High Court Division can declare any act done by a person performing functions in connection with the affairs of the Republic or of a local authority to have been done without lawful authority and to be of no legal effect. Banglapedia notes that this remedy is wider than the classical writ of certiorari, because it reaches acts of any authority, not only those of courts and tribunals. A city corporation is a local authority, and it is under this kind of provision that a lease notice issued by one can be challenged.

Qurbani markets and the scale of sacrifice
Temporary cattle markets are needed because of the size of the qurbani. Banglapedia describes Eid-ul-Azha, popularly known in Bangladesh as Kurbanir Eid or Bakra Eid, as one of the two main Muslim festivals. It is observed on the 10th of Dhul Hijjah, and the sacrifice may also be offered on the following days. Animals offered for sacrifice must be of a specific age and free from certain defects. Cows, goats and buffaloes are usually sacrificed in Bangladesh, and a cow or buffalo may be sacrificed on behalf of seven people while a goat or sheep counts for one. The time of sacrifice begins after the Eid prayer, and part of the meat is distributed to the poor, which Banglapedia says gives the occasion its social, festive character. Some people also import camels for the purpose.
The figures for the previous Eid show how many animals pass through the markets. According to information from the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock reported by The Daily Star's Bengali edition on 30 June 2023, a total of 1,00,41,812 animals were sacrificed across the country at Eid-ul-Azha in 2023, which was 91,049 more than the year before. The number of animals available for sacrifice that year was 1,25,36,333.
The ministry's breakdown for 2023 was:
- Cattle: 45,81,060
- Buffaloes: 1,07,875
- Goats: 48,49,328
- Sheep: 5,02,307
- Other animals: 1,242
Dhaka division recorded the most sacrifices in 2023, at 25,48,184 animals, and Mymensingh division the fewest, at 3,85,902. The other divisions recorded 20,51,777 in Chattogram, 21,32,469 in Rajshahi, 9,49,581 in Khulna, 4,30,673 in Barishal, 3,94,039 in Sylhet and 11,49,187 in Rangpur. In 2021, the same report noted, 90,93,242 animals had been sacrificed across the country.
Much of the animal trade in the capital takes place in the few days before Eid at the leased markets, which is why the choice of sites draws attention each year from residents, lease holders and the city corporations alike. In April 2024, the legal notice over Aftabnagar asked the authorities to drop the site from that year's list within 72 hours, or face a writ petition in the High Court.
Photo: Press Information Department / Wikimedia Commons (public domain). The top picture shows animals at a cattle market in Dhaka in June 2023, as background; it is not Aftabnagar.
Sources: Jagonews24 (15 April 2024), Dhaka Tribune (11 May 2023 and 14 June 2023), The Daily Star Bangla (14 June 2023 and 30 June 2023), Banglapedia (Jahurul Islam; Dhaka City Corporation; Rajdhani Unnayan Kartripakkha; Writ Petition; Eid-ul Azha)





Comments
(0)