Alleging that a great deal of farmers' fruit was once destroyed 'in the name of formalin', fruit expert Dr Md Mehedi Masud, former project director of the 'Nutrition Improvement through Year-round Fruit Production' project, has demanded that those responsible be brought to justice and that the affected farmers be compensated. He made the demand at a roundtable titled 'Fruit Processing: Problems and Prospects' held at the Jago News office in Badda, in the capital, on 27 June 2026. Much of the public fear over formalin and carbide, he said, rests on misconceptions.
A demand for trial and compensation
'At one time a great deal of farmers' fruit was destroyed in the name of formalin,' Dr Mehedi Masud told the roundtable. 'Let those who did it be brought to justice and let those farmers be compensated.' This is his allegation and demand, not a court finding. He said the drives that destroyed fruit on the claim that it contained formalin should be answered for, and that those who conducted them should be brought to justice. The roundtable was organised by the news agency Jago News, where speakers discussed the problems and prospects of the fruit-processing industry.
The idea that formalin is put on fruit has a very weak basis in reality, Dr Mehedi said; in his words, 'nobody has ever put formalin on fruit and nobody will.' He told consumers they have no reason to worry if they wash fruit bought from the market well in clean water, and that people should ignore rumours and eat fruit regularly. Fruit and vegetables are an important part of a healthy diet: the World Health Organization advises everyone over the age of 10 to eat at least 400 grams of fruit and vegetables a day. The WHO advises about 250 grams a day for children aged 2 to 5 and 350 grams for those aged 6 to 9. Speakers at the roundtable held that when baseless panic drives down fruit consumption, it is bad for public health too.

What formalin is, and why it does not act on fruit
Chemically, formalin is an aqueous solution of formaldehyde; a solution of roughly 37 per cent formaldehyde is what is commonly called 'formalin'. It is used mainly as a disinfectant and in laboratories to preserve animals or animal tissue (tissue fixation). Formaldehyde reacts with the amino groups of proteins, first forming a methylol and then a Schiff base, creating cross-links that make tissue firm and stable. As Dr Mehedi Masud put it: 'Formalin acts only on protein. Fruit contains less than 1 per cent protein, so what would formalin do in fruit? Nothing.'
Formaldehyde also occurs naturally, in small amounts, in many ordinary foods. Chemical reference data put the formaldehyde content of food generally at 1 to 100 milligrams per kilogram, and the human body itself forms formaldehyde through metabolism, keeping it in the blood at about 50 micromolar before quickly converting it to formic acid. At the roundtable Dr Mehedi likewise said: 'Some formalin forms naturally inside fruit... and there is a safe dose; 2 to 60 ppm does the body no harm.' That specific figure is his own statement.
Chemical reference data add that the human body itself produces formaldehyde through the metabolism of amino acids such as serine and threonine, quickly breaking it down to formic acid. Nor does formaldehyde persist in the environment: sunlight, or bacteria in soil and water, break it down within a few hours. Among foods, fish, seafood and smoked ham are noted to carry relatively more formaldehyde, and the formaldehyde in food is generally bound and unstable in aqueous solution. For that reason, even if formalin were sprayed on a fruit's surface, it would readily evaporate or wash off, with little real chance of penetrating the peel and persisting inside.
The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classifies formaldehyde as carcinogenic to humans (Group 1). That risk, however, is linked mainly to long-term, high-level exposure by breathing it in air, and is associated with cancers of the nose and throat. In air, levels above about 0.1 ppm can irritate the eyes and the respiratory tract. Conflating this occupational, inhalation risk with the tiny natural amount of formaldehyde in washed, eaten fruit is not scientifically sound. Anyone with a specific health or dietary concern is best advised to consult a doctor or a nutritionist.

The drives, and the confusion over measuring devices
Dr Mehedi Masud's remarks recalled the drives of the past, in which tonnes of fruit were destroyed after being declared to contain formalin. He said officials inserted machines meant to measure formalin in the air into fruit and then declared that the fruit contained formalin. In reality, such handheld devices are built to detect formaldehyde in air, not to measure accurately the level inside a fruit. 'Someone said there was 10 ppm, called it formalin, and tonnes upon tonnes of crops were destroyed. This was only out of ignorance,' he said. That assessment is his own; he said the magistrates who ran the drives should also be brought to justice.
To curb the misuse of formalin, the Formalin Control Act was enacted in 2015, placing the import, production, transport, storage and sale of formalin under licence-based control. Alongside it, the Bangladesh Food Safety Authority, set up under the Food Safety Act 2013, oversees the use of harmful chemicals in food. The purpose of these laws and bodies is to protect consumers while also sparing farmers real losses caused by faulty measurement or baseless assumptions.
Climacteric and non-climacteric fruit
Dr Mehedi Masud explained that not all fruit ripens the same way after it is picked. Fruit is generally of two kinds, climacteric and non-climacteric. In climacteric fruit such as mango, banana and apple, respiration rises sharply at ripening and, driven by the hormone ethylene, starch slowly turns to sugar even after harvest, so the fruit ripens further and grows sweeter. In non-climacteric fruit such as pineapple, orange or malta, this change scarcely happens after picking, so such fruit must be harvested when mature on the tree.
According to plant science, climacteric fruit shows a simultaneous surge in ethylene production and carbon-dioxide release at the onset of ripening; this 'burst' ripens the fruit evenly. Non-climacteric fruit generally will not ripen fully once detached from the plant. That is why many fruits can be harvested unripe and ripened later under controlled conditions, as bananas are picked green and ripened at their destination after shipment. Understanding this difference makes it easy to decide when a fruit should be picked and how it should be stored.
In the plant, ethylene is made from the amino acid methionine, which becomes S-adenosyl methionine, then ACC (1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid), and is finally oxidised to ethylene. In immature fruit, ethylene suppresses its own synthesis, so the fruit does not ripen early. In mature fruit the process reverses into an autocatalytic loop, where a little ethylene triggers more, ripening the fruit quickly and evenly. The peak of respiration usually marks the fruit's best eating ripeness; after it, the fruit becomes vulnerable to fungal attack and begins to degrade.

Carbide banned, ethylene natural
Setting out the difference between calcium carbide and ethylene in ripening, Dr Mehedi said calcium carbide is banned. On contact with water it produces acetylene gas, which can ripen fruit much as ethylene does but may be harmful to health. Industrial-grade carbide can carry toxic impurities derived from arsenic and phosphorus (phosphine and arsine), which is why the use of carbide to ripen fruit is illegal in many countries.
Ethylene, by contrast, is a natural plant hormone produced inside the fruit itself that drives ripening. According to Dr Mehedi, large quantities of fruit can, if needed, be ripened safely at once using ethylene to set international standards and supplied to the market, and this is the method followed worldwide. He warned that lumping banned carbide together with approved ethylene creates needless fear and reduces fruit consumption.
Commercially, catalytic ethylene generators and sensors are used to control the gas concentration and ripen fruit safely. Even at home, keeping fruit in a covered container lets ethylene and carbon dioxide build up around it and speeds ripening. The key point is that ethylene is the plant's own hormone, a natural regulator of ripening rather than a toxic chemical imposed from outside, whereas the acetylene produced from carbide, though it mimics ethylene, is not a plant hormone, and it is the impurities that come with industrial carbide that are the real concern.

Controlled-atmosphere technology for storing fruit
Controlled-atmosphere technology is effective for keeping fruit for long periods, Dr Mehedi said. In this method the oxygen in the store is reduced and replaced by raising nitrogen or carbon dioxide; this slows the fruit's respiration so it can be kept in the same condition for a long time. The method is used around the world to keep apples and other fruit fresh for months.
The technology works particularly well for climacteric fruit, because lowering oxygen and raising carbon dioxide slows both the action of ethylene and respiration, keeping ripening in check. Temperature and humidity matter here too; a suitably cool temperature lowers metabolism and helps keep fruit fresh. In a country like Bangladesh, where mangoes and other seasonal fruit come to market together over a short window, such storage and processing technology can play a large part in cutting waste.
In his own research, Dr Mehedi said, mangoes kept well for up to 25 days in a controlled environment at 10 to 12 degrees Celsius. A 2024 trial with mangoes worth about Tk 25 to 30 lakh also showed that mangoes stay good for three to four weeks with this method. These figures are as he stated them. Extending the shelf life of seasonal fruit can ease the twin problems of prices collapsing at the height of the season and surplus fruit going to waste, which ties directly to the 'fruit processing' prospects the roundtable discussed.
Bangladesh's mango and fruit context
Mango matters most in Bangladesh's fruit economy. The mango (botanical name Mangifera indica) belongs to the family Anacardiaceae. According to Banglapedia, the country has nearly 100 mango cultivars, and superior varieties are grown mainly in the Rajshahi, Nawabganj (Chapainawabganj) and Dinajpur regions. Banglapedia records that about 639,820 tonnes of mango were produced in 2005-06, though output fluctuates from year to year with the weather. Mango trees generally flower in January to March, and fog, rain or cloudy weather during that period can harm fruit set. Young fruit is green and, when ripe, turns greenish-yellow, yellow, orange or reddish depending on the variety, while some cultivars stay green even when ripe.
June is the height of the national mango season, and it is then, each year, that debate over formalin and carbide peaks; when baseless panic spreads, growers in mango regions such as Chapainawabganj and Rajshahi suffer. Speakers at the roundtable held that an expanded fruit-processing industry could turn the season's surplus into juice, pulp, pickle or dried fruit instead of letting it spoil, helping secure fair prices for farmers and cut waste.
The roundtable's speakers and appeal
Moderated by Jago News editor K M Ziaul Haque, the roundtable was also addressed by agricultural economist Dr Jahangir Alam Khan, former vice-chancellor of the University of Global Village; Dr Md Golam Ferdous Chowdhury, chief scientific officer of the Post Harvest Technology division of the Bangladesh Agricultural Research Institute (BARI); Mohammad Arifur Rahman, director of the exportable mango production project; Enamul Haque, deputy director (food and agriculture) of BSTI; PRAN Group managing director Eliyas Mridha; Hashem Foods Limited managing director Md Abul Hashem; former BAPA general secretary Md Iktadul Haque; CAB vice-president S M Nazer Hossain; Kaju and Coffee Agro executive director Md Mahatab Ali; and agri-entrepreneurs Ismail Khan Shamim of Chapainawabganj and Sohel Rana of Naogaon.
The keynote of the meeting was to make consumers aware on the basis of scientific information rather than spreading needless panic over fruit, and to advance the country's fruit-processing industry. Dr Mehedi Masud argued that staying firm against banned carbide while freeing approved ethylene and modern storage technology from misunderstanding would benefit both farmers and consumers.
Photo: Yahya / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Sources: Jagonews24; Wikipedia (formaldehyde, climacteric fruit and the chemistry of ripening); Banglapedia (mango); International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC); World Health Organization (WHO).





Comments
(0)