In May 2018 a small crowd gathered at Fatema Begum's house in Chakulia village, in the Betaga union of Fakirhat upazila in Bagerhat. People had travelled from far away to buy seed of a rice her family had grown. Some walked out to see the field where it stood. But the seed had run out a few days earlier, and most of them went home empty-handed.
The rice had already been given a name by its neighbours: "Fatema dhan", after the woman who found it. Reports said its panicles carried more than a thousand grains each, far more than common varieties. Three years later, in April 2021, a young farmer in Alfadanga upazila of Faridpur was waiting to harvest his own first crop of it, grown from seed he bought after watching videos on YouTube.
This report tells that story as it stood in April 2021: how the rice was found, what the family and local agriculture officials said about it, how it reached Faridpur, and what had and had not been established about it. It also explains why seed picked out of a hybrid rice field raises questions, and how a rice variety becomes an approved variety in Bangladesh.
Three unusual panicles in a hybrid rice field
Fatema Begum said the story began in the Boro season of 2016. While the hybrid rice Aftab-5 was being harvested on land next to her house, she noticed three panicles that looked different from the rest. They were much bigger, and they held far more grains.
Speaking to the news agency UNB in May 2018, she said: "Those sheaves were much longer than others and the number of grains was almost double." She took the three panicles home, dried and processed them, and kept the grain as seed.
The next season she asked her son, Lebuat Sheikh, to grow the seed separately. That first small planting gave about two and a half kilograms of grain, according to the family. She kept all of it as seed again. In the following season the family raised seedlings and planted about 42 decimals of land.
Lebuat Sheikh said that plot lay inside a one-and-a-half-bigha fish enclosure (gher) beside the house. He said the family gave it the same ordinary care as any other rice. By his account they applied 20 kg of urea and 30 kg of potash in two doses, and sprayed pesticide twice against insects. These are the amounts the family reported using, not a recommendation; fertiliser and pesticide doses should come from the local agriculture office.
According to Lebuat Sheikh, the plot produced about 2,600 kg of paddy. He said the family kept some seed for itself and sold the rest at Tk 400 a kilogram, earning Tk 7 lakh 20 thousand. Buyers, he said, came from Sylhet, Rajshahi, Satkhira, Khulna and other districts.
Fatema Begum also said the rice looked like BRRI dhan28, the Boro variety of the Bangladesh Rice Research Institute (BRRI) that was then the most widely grown in the country.
A later account, published by Bangla Tribune on 18 April 2021, tells the start a little differently. It says Lebuat Sheikh found the three panicles while farming the family land on his mother's advice, that the panicles gave two kilograms of seed, and that one bigha sown with that seed gave him 35 maunds, where other rice there did not give more than 18 maunds a bigha. It also says Lebuat named the rice after his mother. These figures are the family's and the reporters' accounts; no field trial by a research institute had measured them.

What the Fatema rice plant looks like
The reports of 2018 and 2021 describe a plant that stood out in the field. The descriptions below are the ones given in those reports and by local agriculture staff; they were not the results of a formal variety trial.
- One seedling is planted per hill, and it grows into 8 to 12 tillers.
- Each plant is 115 to 130 centimetres tall.
- Each panicle is 36 to 40 centimetres long.
- Each panicle holds 1,000 to 1,200 grains, weighing 30 to 35 grams.
- The leaves are about 88 centimetres long; the flag leaf, the leaf just below the panicle, is about 44 centimetres.
- The leaves are about an inch and a half wide.
- The stem and leaves look rather like sugarcane and are stiff, which the reports said keeps the plant from lodging (falling over) in wind and rain.
The reports put the yield at about 130 maunds an acre. That figure was repeated in the 2018 story and again in April 2021, but it came from local accounts, not from a measured trial.
Motahar Hossain, an official of the Department of Agricultural Extension (DAE), gave UNB a more detailed account in May 2018. "This variety is cultivated in the Boro season," he said. "The seedbed was prepared in November and planted at the end of December. This type of rice can be harvested within 150 to 155 days of planting."
He said the average plant length was 115 to 130 centimetres, the number of tillers eight, and the average length of each panicle 36 centimetres. He put the yield above 11 metric tonnes a hectare.
For comparison, BRRI dhan28 gave about 6 tonnes a hectare, according to The Daily Star in October 2017. The newspaper called it the most productive rice variety in the country at that time.

What agriculture officials said
Md Solaiman Ali, the sub-assistant agriculture officer for the Maskata block in Fakirhat, said his office supervised the rice after it was planted, and that the grower followed their advice. He told UNB that they "felt encouraged" seeing the high yield potential of the rice.
Local agriculture officials also sent samples. UNB reported in May 2018 that the samples went to the Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation (BADC) and the Soil Resource Development Institute (SRDI) for tests and research. "Rice samples have been sent to Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation and Soil Resource Development Institute for further research," Motahar Hossain said.
BADC is the state corporation that, among other tasks, distributes seed to farmers and runs seed multiplication farms, according to Banglapedia; SRDI is the government institute for the country's soils. The reports up to April 2021 did not say what those tests found. None of them carried a statement from BRRI, the institute that breeds and tests rice varieties for Bangladesh.
In April 2021 the agriculture officer of Alfadanga upazila, Ripon Prasad Saha, spoke more boldly. He said the Fatema variety, developed by a farmer in Bagerhat, had many special features, and that its yield could astonish not only the country but the whole world. He said it could help meet the country's food shortfall and could even be exported.
He said farmers in his upazila were being encouraged to grow more of it. He also welcomed the trial in his area and said farmers in remote areas would benefit from local farming videos on YouTube. These were his own views as reported in April 2021; they were not the findings of a variety trial.
A YouTube-inspired trial in Alfadanga, Faridpur
By the Boro season of 2020-21 the rice had reached Faridpur. In Helencha Paschimpara village of Alfadanga upazila, a young farmer named Riazul Islam planted it on 75 decimals of his land.
Riazul Islam said he learned about Fatema rice from several videos on YouTube. He said he waited about six months before he could collect seed from Lebuat Sheikh's mother in Bagerhat. In mid-April 2021, as Bangla Tribune reported on 18 April, the crop had begun to ripen, and harvest was expected to start in eight to ten days.
"In all, it cost Tk 10,000 for the 75 decimals," he told Bangla Tribune. "Because I was not at home, I could not look after the rice properly. Even so, I hope to get 95 to 100 maunds." He said steps should be taken to spread the rice across the upazila.
Riazul Islam also said he hoped to profit from the rice, to become self-reliant, and to plant more land with it in the coming season. At the time of these reports his crop was still in the field, so his figure was an expectation, not a harvest.

Fakirhat and Alfadanga: where the rice was grown
Fakirhat is an upazila of Bagerhat district in the Khulna division. Banglapedia, the national encyclopedia, gives its area as 160.68 square kilometres and lists eight unions, Betaga among them. Its main rivers are the Rupsa and the Bhairab.
Paddy, jute, potato, betel leaf and vegetables are its main crops, and agriculture is the main source of income for 53.63 percent of households, according to Banglapedia. The upazila also had 8,779 fisheries, including shrimp farms, which explains why the Fatema rice plot lay inside a fish enclosure: in this part of the south-west, rice and fish often share the same low land.
Bagerhat district, formed in 1984, covers 3,959.11 square kilometres and stretches down to the Bay of Bengal. The 2011 census counted 1,476,090 people there, and 137,789 in Fakirhat.
Alfadanga is the smallest upazila of Faridpur district in the Dhaka division, with an area of 127.87 square kilometres and six unions. The Madhumati is among its main rivers. Banglapedia lists paddy, jute, groundnut, wheat, potato, kalai, onion, garlic and sugarcane as its main crops, and agriculture as the main income source for 56.15 percent of households. The 2011 census counted 108,302 people in the upazila.
Why seed from a hybrid field raises questions
The Fatema rice began as three odd panicles in a field of hybrid rice. That origin matters, because hybrid rice behaves differently from ordinary rice when its seed is saved.
Hybrid rice seed is produced by crossing two genetically different parents, the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) explained in its magazine Rice Today in 2007. The first generation, called F1, shows heterosis, or hybrid vigour, and gives higher yields.
But the grain that an F1 hybrid crop produces is not uniform. IRRI wrote that "grains produced by inbred varieties are almost genetically identical to their parents and so can be saved and planted later." If a farmer plants seed saved from a hybrid crop, "the resultant plants will display widely varying traits," much as brothers and sisters differ from one another. That is why farmers who grow hybrid rice buy fresh seed every season.
A few unusual plants in a hybrid field can therefore be offspring of the hybrid that differ from their neighbours, or plants of some other origin. Only breeders' tests over several seasons can show what such a line is and whether it stays true to type. As of April 2021, the published reports did not say that BRRI or another research institute had carried out such tests on Fatema rice or reported on its origin.
Bangladesh had seen a farmer-found rice before. In the early 1990s Haripada Kapali, a farmer in Jhenaidah Sadar upazila, picked out some plants with slightly different traits from his field of BR 11, a BRRI variety. He planted their seed in 1992, got a higher yield than BR 11, and shared the seed with his neighbours. The rice became known as Haridhan.
When Haripada Kapali died in July 2017, the Dhaka Tribune reported that agricultural officials and scientists were "yet to discern its origin". It described Haridhan as very similar to BR 11 but slightly taller and higher yielding.
How a rice variety becomes an approved variety
A farmer may name a rice after his mother, and neighbours may buy its seed, but in law that does not make it a released variety. The Seeds Act 2018 (Act No. VI of 2018), which replaced the Seeds Ordinance of 1977, sets the rules.
Under section 7 of the Act, the government may declare crops or varieties "notified" to regulate the sale of their seed. A new variety of a notified crop, "developed by any government institution or individual", is released only with the approval of the National Seed Board, on the recommendation of the committee it sets up, and is registered by the Board.
Section 11 says no seed dealer may sell or offer to sell seed of a notified crop or variety unless it is registered by the Board, identifiable by crop or variety, meets the set quality standards, and is sealed and labelled. Breaking the terms set for selling seed of notified crops is an offence under section 24, punishable with up to 90 days' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both.
The Seed Certification Agency, set up at Gazipur in 1974 under the Ministry of Agriculture, coordinates the evaluation and release of varieties of notified crops, according to Banglapedia. It also certifies breeder and foundation seed and tests seed sold in the market.
The route for a new rice is long. When the National Seed Board approved BRRI dhan81 in October 2017, BRRI's director general Md Shahjahan Kabir told The Daily Star that the crossing, laboratory and field tests had continued for 15 years before the board gave its approval.
The reports on Fatema rice up to April 2021 did not say that it had been submitted for release, tested by the Seed Certification Agency or approved by the National Seed Board. It was, in the reports' words, a rice developed by a farmer, sold and shared from farm to farm.

Boro rice and BRRI dhan28: the background
Fatema rice is a Boro rice, grown in the dry season on irrigated land. Banglapedia says high-yielding Boro rice is harvested in May and June, while local Boro is cut in April and May.
Boro had become the country's biggest rice crop. In August 2020 BRRI reported that the 2020 Boro season produced a record 20.26 million tonnes of rice, despite a 0.71 percent fall in acreage. The previous season, 2019, had produced 20.03 million tonnes on 4.9 million hectares, according to the same report, carried by The Financial Express.
Within that crop, BRRI dhan28 dominated. According to The Daily Star in October 2017, farmers planted BRRI dhan28 on about 45 percent of Boro rice land, and scientists called it a mega variety. It and BRRI dhan29 had been released in 1994, and the newspaper reported that both were losing potential with age.
That is the context in which a rice said to resemble BRRI dhan28 but to carry far bigger panicles drew buyers from across the country in 2018, and farmers in other districts in 2021. Rice matters to every household: The Daily Star reported in 2017 that Bangladeshi consumers depend on rice for over half of their daily calories and protein.
For farmers who want to try a new or unfamiliar seed, the upazila agriculture office of the DAE is the first place to ask, both about the seed's source and about fertiliser, irrigation and pest control for the season.
Photo: Salauddin.hossain / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Sources: The Agro News (original report), UNB (May 2018), Bangla Tribune (18 April 2021), The Daily Star (October 2017), The Financial Express (August 2020), Dhaka Tribune (July 2017), IRRI Rice Today (2007), Seeds Act 2018, Banglapedia





Comments
(0)