On 31 May 2025 the Bengali news site Jagonews24 published, in its agriculture and nature section, a reader's account that asked a plain question: was a palm growing at a home in Morrelganj upazila of Bagerhat a wild date palm, or some other species? The writer, Bilkis Nahar Mitu, a student in the Department of Geography and Environmental Science at Government BL College in Khulna, had been prompted by the news, a few days earlier, that a rare wild date palm had been found in the Dharmapur sal forest of Birol upazila in Dinajpur. She described a palm known in her area as the "atal" tree, said its description matched the reports from Dinajpur closely, and asked the Forest Department to examine it and arrange for its conservation.
Her question linked two very different parts of the country: the dry sal woodland of the north-west, on the border with India's West Bengal, and the tidal country of the south-west near the Sundarbans. It also linked two palms that botanists treat as separate species of the same genus, Phoenix. What follows sets out what the writer observed, what was reported from Dinajpur in mid-May 2025, and what botanical and conservation sources published up to that time say about the plants involved.
The find in Dinajpur that prompted the question
Reports of the Dinajpur find appeared in national newspapers from 11 May 2025. The state news agency BSS reported from Dinajpur on 15 May that khudi khejur, a palm it described as nearly extinct, had been found in the Forest Department's sal plantation in the Dharmapur area of Birol upazila. The forest beat officer of the Dharmapur sal forest confirmed the find by showing the plants and their fruit to the reporter, and said the Forest Department had taken steps to conserve them with due care.
On the spot, BSS found that the plant's leaves and thorns looked like those of an ordinary date palm, while the palm itself was almost stemless. Locally it was known as bon khejur (forest date) or khudi khejur (tiny date). A forest guard who said he had looked after the trees of the forest for 28 years described the fruit: green when small, reddish as it grows, and dark like a ripe jam, the black plum, when mature. He said the fruit, about 4 to 5 centimetres long like a local date, grows at the base of the plant, is sweet, and ripens in the summer months of Baishakh and Jyoishtho.
Local people had eaten the fruit for a long time without knowing much about the plant, BSS reported; the details became known only after Forest Department officials and plant researchers saw it. The chairman of the Dharmapur union parishad said that people used to call it kunji khejur, that he had eaten its fruit as a child while playing in the sal forest, and that local representatives were now working to make people aware so that nobody tore the plants or let cattle and goats eat them.
The divisional forest officer told the agency that more than 150 khudi khejur plants had been found in the Dharmapur sal forest, many of them bearing fruit, and that arrangements had been made to conserve them. He said the palm is native to four countries, India, Pakistan, Bhutan and Bangladesh, and that it did not then exist anywhere else in Bangladesh. According to him, a professor from Jahangirnagar University and senior Forest Department officials visited on 13 May, identified the plant and said it was heading towards extinction. The professor advised that seeds from its fruit be sown to raise seedlings in the Forest Department's nursery. The Forest Department said the sal forest of Birol covers 2,836 acres in 21 mouzas and holds more than a hundred tree species, among them sal, teak, mahogany and karai.
The 'atal' palm in a Morrelganj courtyard
The writer said she was born and raised in Morrelganj upazila of Bagerhat, and that because the Sundarbans is fairly close she had come across many kinds of plants there. One of them is a palm known locally as the atal tree, and one still grows in the courtyard of her family home. As children, she wrote, they used to hear the saying "atale betal hoy" and were told that snakes live under the tree, so they never went near it. After seeing the video from Dinajpur on Facebook, she travelled home from Khulna to look at the tree closely.
Its fruit, she wrote, looks like small dates, and four or five colours can be seen on the same bunch. Unripe fruit is green; a little more mature it turns pale yellowish; when mature it becomes deep orange or somewhat red; and when fully ripe it turns jet black and looks like a ripe jam. She had heard in the video that the Dinajpur fruit was quite sweet, but the fruit from her courtyard tasted bittersweet. Although the ripe fruit is black, the inside is somewhat bluish, and the seed is shaped like a grain of wheat.
She compared the tree point by point with the familiar date palm. Its leaves are like date palm leaves, but where date palm leaves are thick and heavy, these are thin and glossy; date palm leaves stand straight, while the atal's are long and droop. The thorns on the leaf stalks are like the date palm's but narrow, thin and fine rather than thick. The stalks are less hard than date palm stalks and break easily. The main difference, she wrote, is the trunk: the date palm's is thick, while the atal's is thinner even than that of a betel nut palm. A young plant carries many thorns, but they are not seen once it grows a little. The palms grow together in clumps of five or six stems, like a bamboo clump.
The fruit ripens in Baishakh and Jyoishtho, the season in which she was writing; after a bunch is cut, the mature fruits slowly ripen and turn black. The tree is now almost gone from her area as well, she wrote. Her mother told her that people of her generation ate its fruit as children; the writer herself never had. Many people, she wrote, cut off the top of the palm to eat the white inner part, known as "mati", which is prized for its sweet and salty taste, and this had reduced the number of trees.
What the stemless wild date palm is
The palm found in Dinajpur is Phoenix acaulis, a member of the palm family, Arecaceae. The Bangladesh Forest Department's Plants Red List of Bangladesh gives its local names as ban khejur, khudi khejur and khajur, and its English names as stemless date palm and dwarf date palm. The species name acaulis is Latin for "without a stem". As North Carolina State University's Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox explains, the name is a slight misnomer: the stem is present but stays below ground and is out of sight on all but the oldest plants.
NC State Extension describes it as a short palm from northern India, Bangladesh and the Himalayan region, an evergreen perennial whose underground stem produces a few short, stiff, feather-shaped (pinnate) leaves. As in all date palms, the lowest leaflets are turned into sharp spines, and the plants are dioecious: male and female flowers grow on separate plants, so fruit forms only where both are present. The fruits are edible, although the flesh is scant. The writer's article gave the palm's native home as northern India, Bhutan and Nepal; the divisional forest officer in Dinajpur listed India, Pakistan, Bhutan and Bangladesh, and the Bangladesh red list assesses it as a native plant of the country.
Phoenix is a small genus. A study of the genus published in the journal ZooKeys in 2013 counted 14 species, spread from the Cape Verde Islands to South-East Asia, including the economically important date palm of the Middle East, Phoenix dactylifera. The same study noted that Phoenix species are largely interfertile, that many hybrids between them are known or suspected, and that the shortage of useful distinguishing features of form and anatomy makes the species difficult to identify. Earlier genetic work cited in the study grouped Phoenix acaulis with two Asian relatives, Phoenix loureiroi and Phoenix pusilla, and placed the mangrove date palm, Phoenix paludosa, as the closest relative of the pygmy date palm, Phoenix roebelenii, in a separate lineage.
One of five critically endangered plants on the national red list
The stemless date palm was already known to conservationists as one of Bangladesh's rarest plants. In June 2023 the environmental news site Mongabay reported on the country's first-ever red list of plants, which assessed the conservation status of 1,000 species using the criteria of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). The list found that seven plant species had been lost from Bangladesh over the past century and placed five in the critically endangered category: bans pata (Podocarpus neriifolius), the bulborox orchid (Bulbophyllum roxburghii), chaulmoogra (Hydnocarpus kurzii), khudi khejur or the stemless date palm (Phoenix acaulis), and the lamba trias orchid (Bulbophyllum oblongum).
Of the 1,000 species assessed, 127 were classed as endangered, 262 as vulnerable, 69 as near threatened and 271 as of least concern, while for 258 there was not enough information to judge. A Jahangirnagar University professor of botany who was one of the assessors told Mongabay that changing climate, excessive and random human use, deforestation, pollution and inadequate protection of forest areas were behind the losses. The Forest Department's chief conservator called the list a milestone and said the department was already planting native trees on a large scale, with the national herbarium network able to help preserve threatened species. The Forest Department's red list entry for Phoenix acaulis records the critically endangered (CR) category.
Sal forests elsewhere in the country had also been described as losing the palm. In March 2023 Prothom Alo, writing about the sal forests of Gazipur and Tangail, cited a study in Madhupur National Park carried out in 2015 and 2016 by researchers from the University of Freiburg and the University of Chittagong and published in 2017. It recorded 385 plant species from 95 families in the sal forest: 140 trees, 48 shrubs, 135 herbs, 46 climbers, nine ferns, five epiphytes and two parasitic plants. The paper listed bon khejur or khudi khejur, together with rattan and several other plants, among the endangered plants of the sal forest.
The palms of the Sundarbans and the mangrove date palm
Banglapedia, the national encyclopedia, counts about 230 genera and about 2,700 species of palm in the world, mostly in the tropics and subtropics, with at least 20 species growing naturally in Bangladesh and at least five more planted from abroad. It names the nipa or golpata palm (Nypa fruticans) as the most economically important palm of the Sundarbans, a source of leaves for thatching in the coastal districts and a good plant for bees, and names hantal, Phoenix paludosa, as another palm of the Sundarbans. The common khejur of Bangladesh's villages, the source of palm sugar, is yet another species, Phoenix sylvestris.
The Sundarbans, in Banglapedia's description, is the largest single block of tidal mangrove forest in the world, about 200 islands separated by about 400 interconnected tidal rivers, creeks and canals. It was declared a reserve forest in 1875, and its three wildlife sanctuaries came under the UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1997. Bangladesh holds about two thirds of the forest, an estimated 6,000 square kilometres, of which about 1,700 square kilometres is water. The botanist David Prain recorded 334 plant species there in 1903, and of the 50 true mangrove species recorded, the Sundarbans contains 35. Hantal is listed among the dominant plants of the forest's saltwater zone in the south-west, while the moderately saline zone that covers most of the southern parts of Khulna and Bagerhat districts is dominated by sundari.
The Forest Department's red list gives the local names of Phoenix paludosa as hintal, hital, hantal and hetal, and its English name as mangrove date palm; nationally it is assessed as of least concern. On the Indian side of the Sundarbans, a study published in Scientific Reports in December 2022 recorded hental, Phoenix paludosa, as near threatened on the global IUCN list and described it as rare there, found mostly in the core forest areas on uninhabited islands in the interior of the delta.
Singapore's National Parks Board (NParks) describes the mangrove date palm as a clustering palm of southern Asia that grows up to 6 to 7 metres tall in swampy coastal forest. Its arching compound leaves are 2 to 3 metres long, made up of narrow, light green leaflets with a grey underside that hang downwards, and its fleshy purple to black fruits grow in clusters. The palm tolerates waterlogged and saline soils and is grown from seed. NParks also notes, citing a 2009 study in the Dhaka University Journal of Pharmaceutical Science, that the leaflets contain toxic compounds. Researchers at Khulna University included the fruit of Phoenix paludosa among ten edible fruits of the Sundarbans that they collected from the forest between July and September 2017 for a laboratory study published in 2021.

How the published descriptions compare
The article did not name a species for the atal tree, and it did not report any examination of the Morrelganj palm by botanists; it asked for one. The published descriptions show why the question is worth asking. NC State Extension describes Phoenix acaulis as stemless, with a few short, stiff leaves, and BSS described the Dinajpur plants as almost stemless, with fruit at the base of the plant. The writer, by contrast, described a palm with a slender trunk, thinner than a betel nut palm, growing in clumps of five or six stems, with long, thin, glossy leaves that droop.
Several of those features appear in NParks' description of the mangrove date palm: a clustering habit, long arching leaves with leaflets that hang down, and fruit that ripens to purple or black. The local names that the Forest Department's red list records for Phoenix paludosa, hintal, hital, hantal and hetal, are also close in sound to "atal", and Banglapedia places hantal among the palms of the Sundarbans, near which the writer grew up. Both palms, on the other hand, have date-like fruit that darkens as it ripens, and the ZooKeys study is a reminder that Phoenix species are hard to tell apart and can hybridise. A firm answer for a single courtyard palm needs a botanist's examination of the plant, its flowers and its fruit, which is what the writer requested.

Sal forests, the home of the Dinajpur palms
The Dharmapur forest where the stemless date palm was found is a sal forest, a forest type dominated by a single tree, sal (Shorea robusta). Banglapedia classes sal forest as tropical moist deciduous forest and says it covers about 121,000 hectares in Bangladesh, about 32 per cent of the country's forest land. Its distribution is wide but broken, across the drier central and northern parts of the mainland, mostly in Gazipur, Tangail, Mymensingh, Jamalpur, Comilla, Dinajpur, Thakurgaon, Rangpur and Rajshahi districts. The largest belt, the Madhupur Garh, runs about 96 kilometres from north to south between the Brahmaputra and the Jamuna, 8 to 24 kilometres wide.
Sal is valued for strong, durable timber used in house building, poles, boats and furniture. About five hundred undergrowth species have been reported growing with it, because of the particular microclimate of the sal forest. Banglapedia lists the threats these forests face: over-exploitation, deforestation, excessive collection of leaf litter, encroachment and the indiscriminate collection of plants valued as medicine or fodder. In Dharmapur, the union parishad representatives said their concern was that people might tear the khudi khejur plants or let cattle and goats eat them.

Two upazilas at opposite ends of the country
Birol upazila of Dinajpur covers 353.98 square kilometres. Banglapedia records that it is bounded by India's West Bengal on the south and west and by the Punarbhaba river on the east; Birol thana was formed in 1915 and became an upazila in 1984. The 2011 census counted 257,925 people, and agriculture was the main source of income for 70.45 per cent of households, with paddy, wheat, maize, sugarcane, potato, sesame, onion and vegetables among the main crops.
Morrelganj upazila of Bagerhat, about 460.90 square kilometres, lies far to the south, bordered on the south by Sarankhola and Mathbaria upazilas. Its main rivers are the Baleshwari, Ghasiakhali, Panguchhi, Bhola and Balbunia. Morrelganj thana was formed in 1909 and became an upazila in 1985, and the 2011 census counted 294,576 people there. Sarankhola, its southern neighbour, is one of the four administrative ranges into which, according to Banglapedia, the Sundarbans is divided. Government BL College, where the writer studies, stands at Daulatpur in Khulna; it began as the Hindu Academy in July 1902, and its first classes were held on 27 July that year.
The writer's appeal to the Forest Department
Much of the atal tree's description, the writer wrote, matched the wild date palm found in the sal forest at Birol, and she wanted someone from the Forest Department to come and examine the tree at her home to see whether it was a wild date palm or another species. Her appeal was for arrangements to conserve it. If it was not the wild date palm, she argued, then the atal tree was itself nearly extinct in her area under its own local name, and conservation would give it a chance to survive.
In Dinajpur, the steps reported in May 2025 were conservation of the plants found in the Dharmapur forest, awareness work by local representatives to keep people and livestock away from them, and the visiting professor's advice to raise seedlings in the Forest Department's nursery from seed. The red list that placed the stemless date palm among the country's five critically endangered plants was described by the Forest Department's chief conservator in 2023 as a vital tool for conserving plant species, and he called for further study of the 258 species whose status could not yet be judged.
Photo: Krzysztof Ziarnek, Kenraiz / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0). The top picture shows Phoenix acaulis (wild date palm) in Auckland Botanic Gardens, New Zealand, as background.
Sources: Jagonews24 (31 May 2025), BSS (15 May 2025), Mongabay (23 June 2023), Bangladesh Forest Department Plants Red List of Bangladesh, NC State Extension Gardener Plant Toolbox, NParks Flora & Fauna Web (Singapore), ZooKeys (2013), Preventive Nutrition and Food Science (2021), Scientific Reports (December 2022), Prothom Alo (23 March 2023), Banglapedia





Comments
(0)