Safe milk cannot be secured by regulation and testing alone, argues Kuldeep Sharma, chief thinking officer at Suruchi Dairy Advisor, an initiative of Suruchi Consultants in Noida, in a Down To Earth column for World Antimicrobial Resistance Awareness Week. India's veterinary extension, he writes, must learn to listen to farmers and make disease prevention pay. The views are the writer's own.
Extension programmes, in his experience of several decades in Indian dairying, start from agendas fixed in advance and count trainings held rather than practices changed. He recalls a session in Rajasthan on Azolla supplementation and ethnoveterinary practice: the farmers said their animals had refused Azolla, that low solids-not-fat, not low milk fat, was their problem, and the women named post-calving prolapse as their main worry, which the two-hour session had not touched.
In another case a cow kept getting mastitis despite repeated treatment. Only when the vet asked about the daily routine did it emerge that one cloth was used to wipe several animals and that the cow lay down straight after milking. A clean towel for each animal, teat disinfection and fresh feed after milking to keep the cow standing for about 30 minutes broke the cycle. Success, Sharma writes, is whether the vet understood the farmer's problem.
India's dairy farms differ too much for one model, he argues: two buffaloes in Rajasthan, three cows kept by a woman in Bihar and a commercial unit in Punjab face different limits on feed, water, vets and money. Clean bedding, hygienic milking, teat disinfection, good nutrition, vaccination and early diagnosis cut infections and antibiotic use. Validated ethnoveterinary practice may have a place under veterinary supervision, but homeopathy, which lacks reliable evidence for conditions such as bovine mastitis, should not be sold as a proven alternative to antibiotics. Vets must explain each medicine's withdrawal period so farmers know when milk can re-enter the food chain.
Then there is the cost. A farmer supplying 20 litres a day could lose the equivalent of 80 litres during a four-day withdrawal period, Sharma calculates. He cites a large dairy that paid an extra ₹1 a litre for milk meeting its antibiotic-residue standard, paid directly to the woman managing the animals: about ₹600 a month for a 20-litre household, and an incentive to separate milk from treated animals. Withdrawal milk must not enter the food chain, and feeding it to calves or pigs carries its own resistance risk, so safe disposal deserves attention. He proposes a National Contaminant-Free Milk Mission, modelled on India's campaign against foot-and-mouth disease.
Photo: ILRI, Stevie Mann / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Source: Down To Earth





Comments
(0)