On 20 February 2025 the news portal Jagonews24 published an opinion column, dated 18 February, by Shahana Huda Ranjana, a communications specialist and columnist, under the headline "None of us is safe from people who kill helpless animals". The writer argued that cruelty to animals and birds in Bangladesh, which is rarely punished, grows from the same mindset as the beating of people by mobs. She built her case on a run of incidents reported over the previous months and years: a nilgai slaughtered by villagers in Ranishankail, Thakurgaon; wild animals seized from an unlicensed zoo in Dinajpur; dead turtles on the Cox's Bazar coast; bird meat sold in Sylhet restaurants and migratory birds poisoned on the Padma at Rajshahi; a horse killed in Rajbari; and stray dogs and cats poisoned at Japan Garden City in Dhaka. This report sets out her argument and checks each incident against the news reports of the time and the laws then in force.
The columnist's argument
Ranjana opened by saying that what people now call "mob" or "mobocracy" is nothing new, and that human brutality is not directed only at people: in her words, animals and birds, trees, hills, soil and rivers are not spared either, and the brutality becomes acute in certain situations. Just as people kill other people for no reason or for trivial reasons, beating them to death, beheading them or burning them, she wrote, they also treat animals and birds cruelly for no reason.
Animals cannot speak, she argued, have no conflict of interest with people and do them little harm. Yet people kill them at will, treat them cruelly, cage them, abandon them, injure them, burn them and even beat them in groups. Because nobody has to suffer punishment for this, she wrote, people have grown more violent by the day, and one person can now kill another very easily. She called this the mindset from which mob rule is born, and said it was growing by taking advantage of a weak rule of law.
Her conclusion, stated after her first examples and again as the column's last paragraph, was that the practice of beating people to death, the habit of pouring hot water on dogs and cats, hacking them with sharp objects, breaking their legs and killing them with poisoned food all belong together, so that "none of us, you or I, is safe from people who kill animals". She also asked what children learn when they see their guardians kill dogs and cats indiscriminately, and wrote that the animals died writhing in front of everyone but could not complain against anyone, "because they have no language".
A nilgai slaughtered in Ranishankail, Thakurgaon
The column's first example was a nilgai that villagers in Ranishankail upazila of Thakurgaon chased, held down and killed. The writer placed it "two years ago". Her description matches, almost word for word, a Prothom Alo report of 12 May 2022. That report said the animal was spotted running about near homes in the Mondolpara area at about noon that day and was chased and caught; it fell to the ground kicking its legs, about ten villagers held it down and one of them cut its throat. The paper said the villagers slaughtered it to eat its meat, and that a video of the capture and the slaughter had spread on Facebook.
According to Prothom Alo, the chairman of the local Dharmagarh union parishad said the nilgai had crossed the barbed-wire border fence from India before running into the village. Two uniformed members of Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB) stood by. The director of BGB's 50 Battalion told the paper that its members did not have the strength to stop so many people, that the same members had earlier rescued a nilgai at the moment of slaughter, and that elected local representatives should have come forward to save the animal alive. The assistant commissioner (land) of Ranishankail said that when he reached the spot at about 3 pm the villagers had already slaughtered it.
The upazila nirbahi officer told Prothom Alo that the villagers had not done right in slaughtering an endangered animal, and that the forest department had been informed and would take legal action. A wildlife inspector of the department's wildlife and nature conservation division in Rajshahi said he had set out from Rajshahi and that legal steps would follow an investigation.
The same report listed earlier cases in the district: a nilgai caught in Jaduar village of Ranishankail on 4 September 2018 and later released in Ramsagar National Park in Dinajpur; another rescued while it was being slaughtered at Shoula Dogachhi in Baliadangi upazila on 24 February 2021; and one that died after villagers chased it at Muktar Basti in Ranishankail on 2 July 2021. Mongabay reported in March 2024 that villagers in Ranishankail had chased, caught and slaughtered another nilgai that crossed from India on 7 January 2024, and had shared out its meat, while one that crossed on 23 November 2023 was caught by border guards with local help and handed to the forest department.
The nilgai, Asia's largest antelope, long gone from Bangladesh
The nilgai (Boselaphus tragocamelus), also called the blue bull, is the largest antelope of Asia. Despite its name, which joins the Hindi words for "blue" and "cow", it is not a kind of cattle. Thakurgaon's district livestock officer told Prothom Alo in 2022 that it looks somewhere between a deer and a cow, that nilgai were once found in India, Pakistan and parts of Bangladesh, and that they were once seen in the fields of Dinajpur, Thakurgaon and Panchagarh but are no longer.
Worldwide the species is not threatened. The IUCN Red List, in an assessment of 2016, lists it as Least Concern because large populations live in India, Nepal and Pakistan, and herds introduced in the 1920s also roam in Texas in the United States. In Bangladesh, however, Mongabay reported that the nilgai was declared extinct in the 1930s. Historically the north-west of the country and neighbouring West Bengal formed the eastern edge of its range, with the Brahmaputra and the Ganges acting as natural barriers, and the animals once lived in the sal forests and floodplains of today's Dinajpur and Rangpur districts.
A 2023 study by researchers in Bangladesh, cited by Mongabay, searched media reports and found 13 cases of nilgai entering the north-west of the country between 2018 and 2022, mostly from India and some from Nepal; the authors suggested that the authorities consider reintroducing the species. A wildlife investigator of the IUCN's Bangladesh office told Mongabay that habitat loss and unchecked hunting had driven the nilgai out of the country, and that a protected area near the Indian border could one day host it again, as long as an education campaign stopped people killing the animals for food. An officer of the forest department's Thakurgaon range told the same outlet that the department's effort so far amounted to asking people in the border areas not to kill nilgai coming from India.
Zoos and the seizure at Swapnapuri, Dinajpur
The writer went on to describe the country's zoos as "known as torture cells for wildlife", where, in her words, animals and birds are handled inhumanely and kept in harsh conditions. She said she had earlier written about the suffering of animals at the National Zoo, that reports had described people's shameless behaviour towards them, and that some people had behaved so vilely towards pregnant monkeys that the monkeys were forced to hide in a corner of their cage. These are the columnist's own descriptions; this report did not find a news report dated before the column that describes the pregnant monkeys.
The National Zoo, also known as Dhaka Zoo, is the largest zoo in Bangladesh. Banglapedia describes it as the national zoo under the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, at Mirpur about 16 km from the centre of Dhaka. It began as a menagerie on the High Court premises in Dhaka in 1964, moved to its present site in 1974 and opened to the public on 23 June that year. It covers about 75 hectares, including two lakes of about 13 hectares that draw thousands of waterfowl every winter.

The column's main zoo example was Swapnapuri, an amusement park with a mini zoo at Khalippur in Nawabganj upazila of Dinajpur, which Prothom Alo described as one of the largest recreation centres in the north, set up in 1989 on about 400 bighas of land. On 26 January 2025 the forest department's Wildlife Crime Control Unit raided the mini zoo on a tip-off and seized 74 wild animals of 22 kinds that, it said, were being kept and displayed without government permission. Prothom Alo listed them as 3 pythons, 4 crocodiles, 4 Asiatic black bears, 17 sambar deer, 5 barking deer, 3 turtles, 12 monkeys, 2 capped langurs, 5 great hornbills, 5 purple swamphens, a heron, 4 lesser adjutant storks, 2 baboons, a hoolock gibbon, a leopard cat and one each of Brahminy kite, black kite, eagle, oriental pied hornbill and otter. The forest department said the animals were seized under section 32 of the Wildlife (Conservation and Security) Act 2012.
The park authority could not show permits for the animals at the time, but claimed it held permits for 52 of them, including the crocodiles, turtles and sambar deer. The wildlife inspector who led the raid told Prothom Alo that those animals were left in the custody of the zoo's curator, with four days to produce the papers, and that they would also be taken if the papers were not submitted; the other 22 seized animals were being moved to the safari park in Gazipur, to be released into its enclosures if they proved fit to adapt.
On 12 February 2025 the unit returned. An inspector of the Wildlife Crime Control Unit told bdnews24.com that 48 animals were recovered from Swapnapuri that day because the park could not show valid papers for the animals left in its custody in January. They included 5 bears, 5 barking deer, 17 sambar deer, 11 monkeys, 5 great hornbills, 2 porcupines and an otter. On the same day the unit recovered 38 animals, including langurs, rhesus macaques, doves and parakeets, from Rabeya Park in Kahalu upazila of Bogura. Five Asian black bears from Swapnapuri were taken into quarantine at the Gazipur safari park, where the officer in charge said their treatment and rehabilitation would continue, and the inspector said the rescued animals would go to the Gazipur and Dulahazara safari parks and other sanctuaries.
The column put the number recovered from Swapnapuri in the two phases at 122, and named hoolock gibbons, an Asiatic bear, capped langurs, great hornbills, slow lorises, otters, snakes and turtles among them. It also said the animals had been kept so carelessly that some were found physically injured, and that they had been displayed only for business, without care. The reports read for this article confirm the two raids and most of those species, but they do not mention slow lorises or injured animals, so those two details rest on the column.
Dead turtles on the Cox's Bazar coast
The column next turned to the sea. Countless dead turtles, it said, were washing up at different points on the Cox's Bazar beach, and researchers had identified them as olive ridleys. The same lines appear in a Prothom Alo report of 26 January 2025. In it a scientific officer of the Bangladesh Oceanographic Research Institute said 68 dead turtles had washed ashore on 25 and 26 January, after 14 more between 4 and 22 January, a total he gave as 84 in 24 days. A team from the institute recovered 12 carcasses between Sabrang Zero Point in Teknaf and Rupapati in Ukhiya, 49 between Rupapati and Sonarpara, and 7 between Pechar Dwip and Himchhari.
For comparison, the institute's figures showed at least 29 dead turtles and 3 dead dolphins found on the Sonadia, Himchhari, Sonarpara, Inani and Teknaf beaches between 1 January and 20 February 2024. The scientific officer said the sea turtle breeding season runs from November to March, when mother turtles come ashore to lay eggs, and that many die then, caught in fishermen's nets or hit by large vessels at sea, though the real cause of the January deaths would be known only after investigation. Researchers, the paper said, read the deaths as a sign that the turtles' breeding grounds were being destroyed.
The conservation organisation Nature Conservation Management (NACOM) told Prothom Alo that mother sea turtles were in grave danger. A survey it carried out in 2003 had found them nesting at 52 points along the Cox's Bazar coast, on quiet beaches from Sonadia in Maheshkhali to St Martin's Island, and its deputy project director said the number had since fallen to 34. A NACOM manager listed the reasons the nesting sites had become risky: unplanned building as tourism grew, lighting on the beach, nets abandoned at sea, and beach diving, games and walking during the nesting season. Illegal current nets fixed on the beach blocked the turtles' path between sea and shore, mother turtles died in trawl nets in the deep sea, and where turtles did manage to lay, dogs ate the eggs and packs of dogs attacked the mothers as they came ashore.
The chief executive of the voluntary environmental group Environment People, cited in both the Prothom Alo report and the column, said dead turtles were found in every breeding season with injury marks on their bodies, because fishermen beat turtles caught in nets fixed in the sea with sticks or struck them with sharp weapons and threw them back into the sea. He said fishermen had to be made aware, the nesting sites made safe and dogs kept off the beach, or the turtles could not be saved. The columnist's own conclusion was that people cannot protect these helpless animals' right to live and lay eggs safely "because we do not recognise their right to live".
The olive ridley (Lepidochelys olivacea) takes its name from its olive-coloured, heart-shaped shell, which grows to about 61 cm; adults rarely weigh more than 50 kg. Females come back to lay their eggs on the beaches where they hatched, digging conical nests in the sand with their hind flippers, and the species is best known for its arribadas, mass nestings in which thousands of females come ashore together, as on the coast of Odisha in India. Most nesting beaches, though, are used by females nesting alone, and some nesting populations exist near Cox's Bazar. The species is listed as Vulnerable on the IUCN Red List and on Appendix I of CITES, the convention on trade in endangered species.

Bird meat in Sylhet and poisoned birds on the Padma
Ranjana wrote that people eat so many things in a lifetime and still their greed does not go. She said she had heard that in some areas near the Sundarbans in Khulna and Satkhira deer meat is still served at weddings, as a special demand from the groom's side, and that migratory birds that come to Bangladesh to escape extreme cold are killed just for their meat. These remarks are hers and are not tied to a specific reported case.
Her next example came from Jaintiapur in Sylhet. Prothom Alo reported on 17 February 2025 that a mobile court led by the upazila's assistant commissioner (land), with an army team, the forest department's Sylhet range officer and police, raided restaurants in the Tarughati area next to Haripur bazar on the night of 16 February. Five restaurants were fined Tk 9,500 each, a total of Tk 47,500 as the paper reported it, and the meat of 150 migratory birds of various species was seized from refrigerators at several other restaurants and later burnt. An earlier raid in the same market on 10 February, carried out under the Wildlife (Conservation and Security) Act 2012, had found cooked bird meat at two restaurants and more in refrigerators.
People involved in the drive told the paper that several restaurants in Haripur had long been accused of selling the meat of various native and foreign birds. The assistant commissioner said some restaurants claimed to be selling duck meat, but it did not look like duck, so samples were kept; some kitchens were also unhygienic and were fined under the consumer rights law, and owners were warned that a repeat offence would bring higher fines. The column added that hotel owners buy the birds secretly from local hunting gangs who, for big profits at little cost, kill them with poisoned bait, which she called a serious threat to public health.
The poisoned-bait example came from Rajshahi. On the morning of 28 January 2025, Prothom Alo reported, officials of the forest department's wildlife and nature conservation division in Rajshahi, dressed as farmers, and the river police caught a 40-year-old hunter from the Sreerampur area of Rajshahi city as he came off a char of the Padma with four dead ducks, three common teal and a piyong duck as the paper listed them. A 300-metre net was seized and burnt, and an executive magistrate sitting as a mobile court on the river bank sentenced him to three days in jail.
That afternoon members of a voluntary group, told that dead birds were floating in the river and lying on the chars, took a boat onto the Padma south of the Rajshahi Police Lines and found 41 dead migratory birds on a single char, including an eagle that died in their hands, a black kite and ducks of various species. They handed the birds to forest officials in the evening. The column wrote that the hunter "admitted" his method. In the Prothom Alo reports, however, the method is described by the forest department's wildlife inspector: the hunter laid poisoned bait on the char at night, collected the dead birds in the morning, cut their throats on the char and supplied them to hotels and restaurants in the city, and he went into the river with a current net as if to fish so that nobody would suspect him.
Prothom Alo added that flocks of migratory birds come to the Padma chars at Rajshahi every winter, that five or six hunters from the city hunt them there with poisoned bait, and that on 9 January the forest department had recovered nine slaughtered ruddy shelducks from a hunter's house in Sreerampur, though the hunter fled when he sensed the officials were there.

A horse in Rajbari and poisoned strays at Japan Garden City
Cruelty, the column argued, is not only for food: people in Bangladesh also kill animals and birds for revenge, pleasure or fun. Its example was a horse in Rajbari that, a few years earlier, had its four legs tied and was brutally killed by having bamboo sticks forced into its anus and urethra; the killers' enmity was with the horse's owner, but it was the horse that died. The same case was described in a Prothom Alo column of 30 November 2024. This report found no dated news report of the incident, so its details rest on those two columns.
The column's last incident took place on 22 November 2024 at Japan Garden City, a gated housing complex in Mohammadpur, Dhaka, where stray dogs and cats were poisoned. The writer described how animals that live on the scraps people give them were called with food that turned out to be laced with poison, and how the dogs and cats ran about in agony and died vomiting blood. These lines follow the Prothom Alo column of 30 November 2024, which said ten street dogs and a cat died that night.
The Dhaka Tribune reported on 23 November 2024 that animal welfare activists staged a sit-in at the main gate of the complex. The poisoned animals had been found on the evening of Friday 22 November, and activists said ten dogs and one cat were killed. An actor and activist filed a written complaint with Adabor police station reporting the recovery of the carcasses of four dogs and a cat and alleging that other carcasses had been hidden to obscure the extent of the poisoning. The complaint accused the secretary of the complex's flat owners' association and other association members of organising the poisoning; the paper said it could not reach the secretary for comment.
The founder of an animal welfare organisation told the Dhaka Tribune that her group had pictorial evidence, that the complex had tried to cull stray dogs before, and that it was preparing a legal case. Banners attributed to a group calling itself "JGC Life Safety" had appeared inside the complex on the Friday evening with messages such as "Send all the stray dogs to dog lovers' households"; the paper could not identify who put them up. A resident alleged that the authorities had told security guards to beat stray dogs, and a security guard denied receiving any such instruction. The officer in charge of Adabor police station said that, as the police do not cover this law, the activists had been asked to file a case in court.
For the columnist, whoever carried out the poisoning, and for whatever reason, were "in fact killers" who would not think twice about poisoning a person and whose hands would not tremble in joining a mob beating. That judgement is hers; the reports of the time named the people accused in the complaint but did not say that anyone had been found responsible.

What the law said in February 2025
The column said that because Bangladesh's wildlife protection law is not very effective, the killing goes on freely. Two laws applied to the cases it raised. The Animal Welfare Act 2019 (Act No. 12 of 2019), dated 10 July 2019 in the official text on the Bangladesh Laws website, repealed the Cruelty to Animals Act 1920. Its preamble says it was made to prevent cruelty to animals, show them kindness and ensure their welfare through responsible care.
Section 6 of the Act lists acts that count as unnecessary cruelty, among them beating an animal needlessly, striking it with a sharp metal object to control it, denying it the food and water it needs, and deliberately and without reason giving it a harmful substance or forcing one into its body by injection or through the anus or genitals. Section 7 says that no ownerless animal may be killed or removed except for reasons given in the Act, and that killing one is an offence. Section 11 makes it an offence knowingly to feed an animal poisonous or harmful food or medicine, or food mixed with poison, or to apply poison to its body, where this causes death, permanent disability or the loss of normal form and function; putting an animal to sleep or giving it a painless death on a veterinary surgeon's written advice is exempt.
Under section 16, offences under sections 6 and 7 carry up to six months' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 10,000, or both, while maiming under section 10 and poisoning under section 11 carry up to two years' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both.
Wild animals are covered by the Wildlife (Conservation and Security) Act 2012 (Act No. 30 of 2012), dated 10 July 2012. Section 6 bars anyone from hunting a wild animal without a licence or permit, and section 39 punishes a breach with up to one year in prison, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both, and up to two years or Tk 1 lakh for a repeat offence. Section 38 punishes the killing of a bird or migratory bird listed in Schedules 1 and 2 with up to one year in prison, a fine of up to Tk 1 lakh, or both, and the collection, possession, purchase, sale or transport of such a bird's meat or body parts with up to six months or Tk 30,000.
Section 37 of the 2012 Act sets up to three years in prison, a fine of up to Tk 3 lakh, or both for killing a listed leopard, clouded leopard, hoolock gibbon, sambar deer, crocodile, gharial, whale or dolphin, several of which were among the animals at Swapnapuri. Section 34 punishes buying or selling wild animal meat or parts from anyone who is not a licence or permit holder with up to one year or Tk 50,000, and section 31 allows the government to form a wildlife crime control unit.
The research the column cited
To support her argument the writer cited three findings from the United States, marked in the column as taken from Prothom Alo; they appear in the same words in the Prothom Alo column of 30 November 2024. In one report, she wrote, the FBI said most serial killers in the United States had a history of cruelty to animals; a well-known 1997 study by Northeastern University and the Massachusetts Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals found that people who are cruel to animals are five times more likely to harm other people; and a 2013 study of school shooters in the United States found that 43 per cent of them used to beat dogs and cats.
The 2013 figure matches a published study. Arnold Arluke of Northeastern University and Eric Madfis of the University of Washington, Tacoma, published "Animal Abuse as a Warning Sign of School Massacres" in the journal Homicide Studies, online on 11 December 2013. According to its abstract, they examined 23 perpetrators of school massacres between 1988 and 2012 and found that 43 per cent had committed animal cruelty before the attack, usually against dogs and cats and in an up-close manner. The abstract also notes that earlier studies gave mixed support to the idea that animal cruelty is a warning sign of later violence against people.
The closest published match found for the 1997 study is a paper by Arluke, Levin, Luke and Ascione in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence of September 1999; the sources read for this report do not confirm that it is the study the column means. It tracked the criminal records of 153 animal abusers and 153 comparison subjects. Its abstract says the abusers were more likely than the others to be violent towards people, but also more likely to commit property, drug and public disorder offences, and that animal abuse was no more likely to come before violent offences than after them. The authors wrote that their findings disputed the assumption that animal abuse inevitably leads to violence towards people, while pointing to an association between animal abuse and a range of antisocial behaviour, violence included. The "five times" figure is not in the abstract and is given here as the column's.
This report did not find the FBI report the column refers to. The FBI did begin, on 1 January 2016, to collect detailed data on animal cruelty, including gross neglect, torture, organised abuse and sexual abuse, in its National Incident-Based Reporting System; until then such crimes had been lumped into an "All Other Offenses" category. In a news story of 1 February 2016 an official of the bureau's criminal statistics unit was quoted as saying, "Some studies say that cruelty to animals is a precursor to larger crime", and the story said the National Sheriffs' Association, which pressed for the change, had for years cited studies linking animal abuse with other crimes, most famously murders committed by serial killers.
Photo: Jayi Rawool / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0). The top picture shows a nilgai crossing water in Keoladeo National Park, Bharatpur, Rajasthan, India, as background; it is not the animal killed in Thakurgaon.
Sources: Jagonews24 (20 February 2025), Prothom Alo (12 May 2022; 30 November 2024; 26 and 28 January 2025; 17 February 2025), Dhaka Tribune (23 November 2024), bdnews24.com (12 February 2025), Mongabay (20 March 2024), Bangladesh Laws website (Animal Welfare Act 2019; Wildlife (Conservation and Security) Act 2012), Journal of Interpersonal Violence (September 1999), Homicide Studies (December 2013), FBI (1 February 2016), Banglapedia, Wikipedia





Comments
(0)