LiveMarket prices
Wheat flour (packaged)58—Ginger (imported)167—Ginger (local)154—Aman rice (medium)56—Aman rice (coarse)48—Aman rice (fine)72—Iodised salt (packaged)32—Green chilli218—Broiler chicken162—Mutton900—Sugar (local)132—Chickpeas (whole)85—Farm eggs (red)47—Onion (local)60—Boro rice (medium)55—Boro rice (coarse)47—Boro rice (fine)66—Beef729—Mung dal122—Garlic (imported)192—Garlic (local)173—Soybean oil163—
Updated 16 November 2026
Dhaka24°Partly cloudyHumidity 82%Wind 5 km/h

A gravedigger's horse and a nilgai: why people harm animals without reason

After an injured nilgai from Panchagarh died at the Dulahazara Safari Park and a Kishoreganj gravedigger's horse was found killed, a Jagonews24 column of 28 May 2025 by Shahana Huda Ranjana asked why people kill animals for no reason.

A gravedigger's horse and a nilgai: why people harm animals without reason
Environment

On 28 May 2025 the news portal Jagonews24 published an opinion column by Shahana Huda Ranjana, a communication specialist and columnist, under the headline "Why do people kill animals for no reason?". Dated 27 May, it was prompted by two incidents reported earlier that month: the death of an injured nilgai that had wandered into Panchagarh from across the Indian border, and the killing of a horse that belonged to Monu Mia, a gravedigger in Kishoreganj who had dug more than 3,000 graves. Her argument was that cruelty to animals is not a private matter between a person and an animal: it harms the animals, it points to wider violence in society, and it has to be met by education, mental health care and the law working together.

Below are the two incidents as newspapers reported them at the time, the background to the nilgai and the places involved, the research the writer drew on, and the laws of Bangladesh that applied to such acts in May 2025.

The nilgai that came to Panchagarh


According to The Daily Star's Bengali edition, the animal was seen around noon on Sunday, 11 May 2025, near a maize field in Sarkarpara village of Garinabari union in Panchagarh Sadar upazila. Women workers picking chillies in a nearby field spotted it first. After it had run through maize and other crop fields for about two hours, village men caught it. Forest Department staff took it to the Panchagarh Social Forestry and Nursery Training Centre for treatment, said Haripada Debnath, the centre's officer in charge. Rezaul Karim, a veterinary field assistant of the Sadar upazila livestock office and veterinary hospital, who gave first aid, said the female was about two years old and had deep wounds on its legs and elsewhere that looked at least six or seven days old. Local people and forest officials said they believed it had been hurt while crossing the barbed-wire border fence from India.

Prothom Alo reported on 13 May that local people had chased the nilgai and caught it, after which forest staff rescued it in an injured state and treated it in a room of the department's staff quarters. On 15 May it was handed over to the Dulahazara Safari Park in Chakaria upazila of Cox's Bazar, where it was treated in the park's wildlife hospital. It died there at dawn on Saturday, 24 May. Chakaria upazila livestock officer Arif Uddin and the park's veterinary surgeon Khatem Zulkarnain carried out a post-mortem that afternoon, and the body was buried inside the park.

The veterinary surgeon told Prothom Alo that when the nilgai arrived it had injury marks on all four legs and on other parts of its body; the joint of its front right leg was broken and the wound was discharging pus. Infection of the wounds, he said, had destroyed the animal's ability to resist disease, and that was why it died. The park's officer in charge, Monjur Alam, said that after this death the park had two nilgai left: a female brought from Panchagarh on 14 April and a male brought from the Gazipur safari park to be her mate, and that both were healthy.

In her column Shahana Huda Ranjana wrote that some local people had beaten and injured the nilgai for no reason, out of pent-up violence, and that when an animal Bangladesh had lost came back across the border, people here did not let it live. The reports of the time describe the animal being chased and caught by villagers and carrying wounds that officials linked at least partly to the border fence; they do not establish who caused each injury.

A view of the Dulahazara Safari Park in Chakaria, Cox's Bazar, where the nilgai from Panchagarh was treated. Photo: Syed Sajidul Islam / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
A view of the Dulahazara Safari Park in Chakaria, Cox's Bazar, where the nilgai from Panchagarh was treated. Photo: Syed Sajidul Islam / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

What a nilgai is


The nilgai (Boselaphus tragocamelus) is the largest antelope in Asia and the only living member of its genus, first scientifically described by Peter Simon Pallas in 1766. Despite its name, which means "blue cow", it is not a cow. Bengali writing often calls it a deer, and the column described it as the largest deer-like animal in Asia, but Nurjahan, the wildlife and biodiversity conservation officer of the Chattogram wildlife management and nature conservation division, told Prothom Alo that it is in fact an antelope. Adults stand 1 to 1.5 metres at the shoulder. Males weigh 109 to 288 kg and females 100 to 213 kg. The sexes look different: adult males have a bluish-grey coat and smooth horns 15 to 24 cm long, while females and young are orange to tawny and have no horns. The animal has a sloping back, thin legs, a white patch on the throat and white spots on the face.

Nilgai are active mainly by day and feed chiefly on grasses and herbs, though they also browse woody plants. They prefer areas with short bushes and scattered trees, scrub forest and grassy plains, are common on farmland and are rarely found in dense forest. They live in small groups: one or two females with young calves, three to six adult and yearling females with calves, or all-male groups of two to 18. Typically tame, a nilgai that is harassed or alarmed may flee 300 metres or more at a gallop. Females become sexually mature at about two years and males not until four or five. Gestation lasts eight to nine months and usually produces a single calf, sometimes twins or even triplets, and the lifespan is about ten years.

The species lives in India, Nepal and Pakistan, with major populations in the Terai lowlands below the Himalayas, and is abundant across northern India, where the population was estimated at one million in 2001. The International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) lists it globally as Least Concern. In several north Indian states its numbers are so large that farmers have asked the authorities to cull it, because herds raid and trample crops.

Bangladesh is a different story. Banglapedia, citing the IUCN Bangladesh red book of 2000, lists the nilgai among more than a dozen wild animals the country lost in the last century, alongside the one-horned, Javan and Sumatran rhinoceroses, the gaur, the banteng, the wild buffalo, the swamp deer, the wolf, the pink-headed duck, the common peafowl and the marsh crocodile. Prothom Alo reported that a hundred years ago nilgai were plentiful in Dinajpur, Thakurgaon and Panchagarh. The Chattogram wildlife officer said that before 1940 they were found in the forests of Thakurgaon, Panchagarh, Dinajpur, Naogaon and Joypurhat, and that they vanished because of the loss of habitat and food and a hostile environment. The few that turn up now, she said, come from India, and most are attacked by local people or hurt on the border fence.

The Red List of Bangladesh 2015, unveiled by IUCN in Dhaka on 22 June 2016, assessed 1,619 animal species in seven groups: mammals (138), birds (566), reptiles (167), amphibians (49), freshwater fish (253), crustaceans (141) and butterflies (305). It classed 390 of them as threatened (56 Critically Endangered, 181 Endangered and 153 Vulnerable), listed 278 as Data Deficient, and recorded 31 species as Regionally Extinct. As Prothom Alo noted in its report of the death, the nilgai is one of those 31.

Nine nilgai in seven years


The Panchagarh animal was not the first. Prothom Alo counted nine nilgai seen in Panchagarh and Thakurgaon between September 2018 and 11 May 2025. Most were sent to safari parks; some died at the hands of crowds. In Panchagarh, a nilgai chased by villagers died at Mirzapur in Atwari upazila on 17 March 2021, and another seen in a maize field in Atwari on 21 May 2023 escaped before anyone could catch it. In neighbouring Thakurgaon, five were found between 4 September 2018 and 13 November 2023: one died after being chased by local people in Ranisankail upazila, another was slaughtered by local people, and three were rescued injured. On 12 May 2022 The Daily Star's Bengali edition reported that a nilgai had been killed in Thakurgaon after a chase of two and a half hours. Nilgai rescues had also been reported from Natore, Naogaon and Chapainawabganj.

Barely a month before the May incident, on 9 April 2025, villagers chased and caught another female nilgai at East Jaydharbhanga, close to the Indian border in Chaklahat union of Panchagarh Sadar. According to The Daily Star, after being chased for about three kilometres it jumped into the local Panga river, where villagers surrounded it. Members of a nearby Border Guard Bangladesh camp rescued it and the upazila nirbahi officer informed the Forest Department. After first aid it was sent on 12 April, in a wooden crate on a truck, to Dulahazara. The park's acting officer said at the time that its vet had found the animal healthy apart from a few light scratches, and that a male would be brought from the Gazipur safari park as a companion. Forest Department sources told the paper that at least six nilgai had been seen in Thakurgaon and Panchagarh since 2018; four were rescued alive and two died after being chased and beaten by villagers.

The wildlife management and nature conservation division of the Rajshahi divisional forest office told Prothom Alo that at least five nilgai from the north had been sent to the Gazipur safari park over the previous few years and that, with calves born there, the number had grown to twelve. Forest officials and animal experts quoted by the paper said the animals cross from India while searching for food, after straying from their herd or when facing adverse conditions, and that most are injured on the border fence. Finding no suitable habitat on the Bangladesh side, they enter villages and shelter in crop fields.

Md Sharif Hossain, a zoology lecturer at Panchagarh Government Women's College, told the paper that the nilgai is a species Bangladesh has lost, that it would enrich the country's biodiversity if it came in, and that the Forest Department and other agencies should run awareness programmes for people in border areas with the help of local government. Haripada Debnath said that although nilgai and other wild animals were caught from time to time in the border district, the Forest Department had no separate officer there for rescuing or conserving wildlife. People involved told Prothom Alo that awareness meetings and seminars on wildlife conservation were needed for border residents.

A gravedigger's horse in Kishoreganj


The second incident was reported by Prothom Alo on 17 May 2025. Monu Mia, 67, of Algapara village in Joysiddhi union of Itna upazila in Kishoreganj, had dug graves for 50 years without taking payment; according to his diary, the count stood at 3,057. Whenever he heard of a death he would ride his horse to the graveyard with a spade, a digging tool and everything else he needed. Some years earlier he had sold his own paddy land to buy the horse so that he could reach distant villages quickly. He had no children. When illness left him bedridden, he was admitted on 14 May to a private hospital in Dhaka, where he was treated in a critical condition with his wife at his side.

With both of them away, there was no one to look after the horse. On the morning of Friday, 16 May, local people found its body lying in water beside a madrasa in Hashimpur Chhatrish village of neighbouring Mithamain upazila, with a wound from a sharp weapon on its chest. Thinking of his physical and mental state, his wife and relatives kept the news from him. His wife told Prothom Alo by phone that her husband had never harmed anyone in his life, that she had always believed people loved him, and that she could not understand how anyone could kill his beloved horse while he was so ill. A neighbour called the killing a condemnable act and said it should be punished.

Mukit Sarkar, the additional superintendent of police (administration and finance) then in charge of Kishoreganj police, told the paper that the officer in charge of Mithamain police station had been instructed to take legal action and that action would follow as soon as a complaint was received. The report named no suspect, and no one had been publicly accused when the column appeared.

Prothom Alo described Monu Mia as well known as a skilled gravedigger across the remote haor upazilas of Itna, Mithamain, Shalla and Ajmiriganj and beyond, including at Banani graveyard in Dhaka, and said he also wrote down the date of death of everyone whose grave he dug. Itna, according to Banglapedia, covers 401.93 square kilometres in the north-east of Kishoreganj; the Surma, Dhanu, Baulai and Kalni rivers and several large haors and beels lie within it, and it became a thana in 1917 and an upazila in 1983.

Shahana Huda Ranjana wrote that since reading the report she had kept asking whether anyone had a grudge against the gravedigger, and what wrong the horse had done. The horse was like a child to him, she wrote, and perhaps someone killed it to hurt him. When envy and hatred take hold, she argued, people turn into monsters and take satisfaction in destroying what the person they resent loves: his wealth, his property, his animals. As other examples of spite she mentioned a banana plantation she had seen hacked to pieces, a pond whose fish had all been killed with poison, and a mango orchard in Rajshahi where every tree had been uprooted with its fruit, while the owner wept and, she suggested, some sick-minded person enjoyed it.

A horse grazing; a background picture, not the horse in the report. Photo: Parvezahmed / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
A horse grazing; a background picture, not the horse in the report. Photo: Parvezahmed / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

What research says about cruelty and violence


The writer turned to research to explain such acts. She began with Charles Darwin, who wrote in The Descent of Man (1871): "There is no fundamental difference between man and the higher mammals in their mental faculties." Animals cannot argue or speak for themselves, she wrote, but they feel, rejoice and suffer, and they serve their owners faithfully; yet because they are helpless they fall victim to human violence. It is not only strays: many people mistreat their own pets, and animals in zoos, circuses, safaris, farms and pet shops are often treated harshly.

She cited a 2009 study linking slaughterhouses with crime. The study, "Slaughterhouses and Increased Crime Rates" by Amy Fitzgerald, Linda Kalof and Thomas Dietz in the journal Organization & Environment, analysed 1994 to 2002 data from 581 non-metropolitan counties in US states with "right-to-work" laws. It found that slaughterhouse employment increased total arrest rates, arrests for violent crimes, arrests for rape and arrests for other sex offences in the surrounding communities compared with other industries. It measured arrest rates in counties, not the records of individual slaughterhouse workers, as the column's wording suggested.

She also cited the Norwegian Centre for Violence and Traumatic Stress Studies. Its national school survey of 9,240 adolescents aged 12 to 16, published in the Journal of Interpersonal Violence in 2022, found that 4 percent had seen a parent be violent towards a family pet and 1 percent had experienced an adult in the household threatening to harm one. The authors reported "a substantial overlap between companion animal abuse and child abuse", most often alongside psychological abuse and less severe physical abuse, and found risk factors similar to those for domestic abuse: low socioeconomic status, and parents' substance abuse, psychiatric illness or history of imprisonment.

A history of torturing pets and small animals is known as zoosadism, and psychiatry treats it as one of the signs of certain disorders, including antisocial personality disorder. The column quoted The New York Times as reporting that the FBI had found a history of cruelty to animals to be one of the traits that regularly appear in its records of serial rapists and murderers, and that the standard diagnostic manual for psychiatric disorders lists cruelty to animals as a diagnostic criterion for conduct disorder. Robert K. Ressler, an agent in the FBI's behavioural science unit who studied serial killers, told the paper in 1991 that murderers like Jeffrey Dahmer very often start by killing and torturing animals as children.

The FBI itself began recording animal cruelty as a separate offence in its National Incident-Based Reporting System on 1 January 2016, covering gross neglect, torture, organised abuse and sexual abuse; before that, such crimes were lumped into an "all other offenses" category. An official of the bureau's criminal statistics unit said then that some studies suggest cruelty to animals is a precursor to larger crime, and the National Sheriffs' Association, which pushed for the change, pointed to its overlap with domestic violence and child abuse.

The column also drew on the psychiatrist Alan R. Felthous, who reported a survey of psychiatric patients who had repeatedly tortured dogs and cats: all of them were highly aggressive towards people as well, and one had murdered a boy. In two studies cited by the Humane Society of the United States, roughly one third of families suffering domestic abuse said at least one child had hurt or killed a pet. Research has also found that children who abuse animals have often witnessed or suffered abuse themselves. That, the writer argued, makes cruelty learned behaviour: if children see that no one is scolded or punished for it, they may come to think it acceptable.

Psychologists call this connection between cruelty to animals and violence against people "the Link". The writer argued that people who lack empathy, as those with antisocial personality disorder do, may hurt animals to show power or relieve stress, and that others vent suppressed anger on animals because they are weak and cannot resist. She was careful, though, to add a caveat from Helen Gavin's textbook Criminological and Forensic Psychology (2013): cruelty to animals is not a universal trait of offenders. Gavin's example is Dennis Nilsen, the former civil servant who murdered at least twelve young men at two addresses in north London between 1978 and 1983 and was sentenced to life imprisonment on 4 November 1983 after being convicted of six murders and two attempted murders. He loved his dog, Bleep, and after his arrest was very worried about her, because she too had been taken to the police station. The column's figure of "at least 15" victims is the top of the range usually given, which runs from 12 to 15.

Cruelty close to home


In Bangladesh, the writer wrote, dogs and cats in the streets are still kicked, stoned, scalded with hot water or poisoned. She listed cases she said had happened: young men in Sylhet who killed foxes and a civet that had taken shelter on a hillock and paraded with the skin of a jungle cat; a deer that took refuge in a house during a flood and was eaten; a group that killed a mother palm civet and left her young without shelter; a dog whose legs were broken; a cat hanged with a rope; injured Asian openbill storks cooked and eaten; and fish, monkeys and birds killed with poison. People who can kill animals without need, she argued, may kill people tomorrow, and the country was already seeing people kill one another with or without reason.

She singled out the pet market at Katabon in Dhaka, where she said animals are kept in inhumane conditions and many died during Covid. That was reported at the time. During the strict lockdown of July 2021, AFP quoted a spokesman for the market's shop owners' association as saying that about 400 birds and dozens of dogs, cats, rabbits, rats and guinea pigs had died since the market shut on 1 July, at least 20 percent of the animals. After the deaths made national headlines, the government ordered police to let the market's 75 small shops open for two hours in the morning and two in the afternoon. Rubaiya Ahmad, head of the animal rights group Obhoyaronno, told AFP that the animals there had already been kept in extremely inhumane conditions and that wherever animals are kept in confinement, they are the first to pay the heaviest price in unusual circumstances.

A zoo is also a prison, the writer argued, where animals suffer neglect, malnutrition, thirst and filth, and the owners and drivers of horse carts in Cox's Bazar and in Dhaka's Gulistan force their horses to carry excessive loads, beat them and underfeed them. Earlier reports describe the problem in Cox's Bazar. In June 2021 The Business Standard reported that, according to the Horses Owners Association, 26 beach horses had died since the pandemic began, 20 of them in 2020 and six in 2021; owners blamed the loss of tourist income, while there were allegations that many owners stopped feeding their horses and let them roam the town for food, where some ate rotten waste from roadside bins and some were hit by vehicles.

In June 2022 The Daily Star's Bengali edition reported that the Cox's Bazar superintendent of police, Mohammad Hasanuzzaman, had told horse owners at a meeting that legal action would be taken against anyone treating the beach horses inhumanely. The paper said the horses carried tourists by day but were left to wander unattended at night, and that owners were accused of neglecting their food, treatment and shelter outside the tourist season, leaving the animals malnourished and sick.

A child who grows up without love for animals, the writer concluded, grows up hard-hearted. She wrote that a lack of empathy and awareness towards animals, gaps in moral education and the sight of cruelty increase violence among children and teenagers, and that young people who grow up without love for nature, animals and people will not be able to love their family, society or country. Preventing cruelty, she argued, needs mental health care, education and the legal system working together.

Horse riding on the beach at Cox's Bazar. Photo: Ferdous / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Horse riding on the beach at Cox's Bazar. Photo: Ferdous / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

What the law said in May 2025


Two laws covered the kinds of acts the column describes. The Animal Welfare Act 2019 (Act No. 12 of 2019, dated 10 July 2019) replaced the Cruelty to Animals Act 1920. It defines an animal as any mammal other than humans, any bird, any reptile, any aquatic animal other than fish, and any other animal the government declares by gazette notification. Its authority is the director general of the Department of Livestock Services or a veterinary surgeon of the department he empowers. Section 4 makes every owner or keeper responsible for treating an animal humanely and for refraining from cruelty without reasonable cause.

Section 6 lists acts that count as unnecessary cruelty. They include:

  • causing an animal's sickness by an act or an omission;
  • overworking an animal or beating it unnecessarily;
  • not giving it enough food and water, or force-feeding it;
  • tying, confining or carrying it so that it cannot stand, sit or lie naturally;
  • striking it with sharp metal objects to control it;
  • releasing a sick animal into a settlement, or releasing an animal there to die;
  • provoking an animal to fight, using it as bait or teasing it;
  • keeping a dog tied or shut in for 24 hours or more without exercise;
  • offering a suffering animal for sale without treatment.

Section 7 says no ownerless animal may be killed or removed except for reasons the Act allows, and makes killing one an offence. Section 8 forbids using a physically unfit animal for transport and loading any animal with excessive passengers or goods. Section 11 makes it an offence to feed or apply poison or harmful substances knowingly if the animal dies, is permanently disabled or loses its normal function, except for anaesthesia or painless death carried out on a veterinary surgeon's written advice.

Under section 16, an offence under section 6, 7 or 8 carries up to six months' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 10,000, or both. Mutilation under section 10 and poisoning under section 11 carry up to two years' simple imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both. Section 19 makes all offences under the Act non-cognisable and bailable.

A wild animal such as the nilgai came under the Wildlife (Conservation and Security) Act 2012, the law in force at the time. Section 6 forbids anyone to hunt any wild animal without a licence or permit under the Act, and the Act defines hunting to include killing, capturing or poisoning a wild animal, chasing it for any of those purposes, and injuring or harming it. Under section 39 a violation of section 6 carries up to one year in prison, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both, and a repeat offence up to two years, a fine of up to Tk 100,000, or both. Section 30 allows the government to set up rescue centres to give injured, seized, abandoned or donated wildlife treatment, food, shelter and security, and to set guidelines for releasing them back into nature.

Photo: Bernard Gagnon / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Sources: Jagonews24, Prothom Alo, The Daily Star (Bengali edition), The Business Standard, AFP (via Geo News), IUCN, Banglapedia, Laws of Bangladesh (Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs Division), Federal Bureau of Investigation, Organization & Environment, Journal of Interpersonal Violence (Europe PMC), Wikipedia

Online DeskThe Agro News

Environment

Related stories

Comments

(0)