On 17 December 2025 Jagonews24 published an opinion piece by Md. Rahmat Ullah, a former college principal, author and columnist, arguing that the quality control of fish and poultry feed in Bangladesh should rest with a single authority, the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, instead of being shared with the Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution (BSTI) under the Ministry of Industries. The column traced how feed makers came to answer to two government bodies, described an inter-ministerial meeting held on 3 September 2025, and asked which institution has the expertise and the reach to guarantee safe fish, meat and eggs for consumers.
The writer's starting point was the growth of farming itself. In his account, a great many fish and poultry farms had grown up, often without planning, to meet the daily protein needs of the country's large population. Most of the people behind the chicken and duck farms, he wrote, were entrepreneurs with little formal education from remote areas who had created their own jobs. Chicken had become the top food preference of the younger generation and was essential for meeting protein needs, and a large number of fast-food shops had sprung up around it, creating still more jobs.
How fish and poultry farming grew
The writer credited the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock with a commendable role in raising fish and poultry output, and the Department of Youth Development with notable work in creating entrepreneurs. Officials posted at upazila level, he wrote, had contributed directly through training and advice, and various NGOs had also played a part. As demand and output grew, so did the demand for fish and poultry feed and medicine, and many firms, most of them small industries, grew up to make them. By his count, about 300 poultry and fish feed producers and marketers were registered with the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock.
Official figures published before the column show the scale he was describing. The Department of Livestock Services (DLS), in its "Livestock Economy at a Glance (2023-2024)", put the number of chickens in the country at 3,277.77 lakh and ducks at 682.61 lakh in the 2023-24 fiscal year. The same sheet gave that year's production as 150.44 lakh metric tonnes of milk, 92.25 lakh metric tonnes of meat and 2,374.97 crore eggs. It estimated livestock's share of gross domestic product at 1.80 percent at constant prices (provisional) and its share of agricultural GDP at 16.33 percent, and it estimated the country's population in July 2023 at 17 crore 58 lakh.
Fish farming had grown in the same way. The Department of Fisheries (DoF), in a table on its portal last updated on 26 June 2025, put total fish production in 2023-24 at 50.18 lakh tonnes: 14.11 lakh tonnes from inland open waters, 29.78 lakh tonnes from closed waters, that is ponds and other farmed water bodies, and 6.29 lakh tonnes from the sea. The department noted that production from closed water bodies was rising very sharply. Farmed fish, like farmed chicken, depend almost entirely on manufactured feed, which is why the quality of that feed was the subject of the column.

A feed industry that supplies most of the country's needs
The Business Standard, in a supplement article of 30 May 2024 drawing on data from the Feed Industries Association Bangladesh (FIAB), reported that investment in the feed sector stood at about Tk 28,000 crore, with an annual production capacity of about 80 lakh tonnes, more than local demand. The industry supplied 65.7 lakh tonnes of feed a year, according to the same report. It gave the demand from poultry as 45.40 lakh tonnes, from fish farms as 13.60 lakh tonnes and from dairy and cattle as 6.70 lakh tonnes. Citing DLS and FIAB data for 2020-21, the paper counted 249 registered feed mills and 83 unregistered ones. Maize made up about 55 percent of feed and soybean meal about 30 percent, it reported, and the price of maize had risen from Tk 17.30 a kilogram in July 2020 to Tk 36 in November 2023.
The column described how these firms had long operated with certificates or approvals obtained by paying fees set by the government's livestock division. Many graduates in veterinary science and aquaculture from the agricultural universities worked in the companies, the writer noted, and their factories had laboratories and testers. The companies claimed that their feed was close to BSTI standards; the writer said that claim needed to be verified in full.
He also took up a charge that had circulated about the sector. Because fish and poultry feed can be made on a very small scale, he wrote, the allegation that more than a hundred unlicensed producers were operating across the country could not be wholly dismissed. If such firms existed, they had to be brought under government control. In his words, it was the government's own duty to make fully certain that no feed maker used tannery waste or other unhealthy ingredients and that feed quality was and remained sound.
His reasoning linked feed to the dinner table. Just as people need food to live, he argued, they need that food to be safe to live healthily. People's health had come to depend largely on the health of farmed fish and poultry, which in turn depended on the quality of their feed and medicine. Feed produced to set standards would prevent disease and pollution and make fish, meat and eggs safe.
What the Fish Feed and Animal Feed Act 2010 says
The law at the centre of the dispute is the Fish Feed and Animal Feed Act 2010 (Act No. 2 of 2010), dated 28 January 2010 and published on the government's legal database, bdlaws. It governs the production, processing, quality control, import, export, marketing, sale, distribution and transport of fish feed and animal feed. It took effect at once and preserved actions taken under the Fish Feed and Animal Feed Ordinance 2008.
The Act defines the "department" as the Department of Fisheries for fish feed and the livestock department for animal feed, and its definition of "animal" includes birds. Under section 3 the Director General of the Department of Fisheries, or an officer he empowers, is the controlling authority for fish feed, and the Director General of the livestock department, or an officer he empowers, is the controlling authority for animal feed. The other main provisions, as the official text sets them out, are these:
- Section 4: no one may produce, process, import, export, market, sell or distribute fish or animal feed without a licence.
- Sections 5 to 7: the two directors general, or first-class officers they empower, are the licensing authorities; a licence is to be issued within 30 days of a complete application and is valid for one year from issue.
- Section 10: the government sets, by rules, the standard levels of the ingredients of commercially produced feed, and following them is compulsory; a maker's licence can be cancelled if a quality control laboratory finds the standard is not met or finds harmful ingredients.
- Section 11: an empowered officer may take samples of imported or locally made feed at any stage of marketing and have them tested; feed found unfit is to be confiscated.
- Section 12: feed containing substances toxic or harmful to people, animals, fish or the environment, or feed that does not match the standard levels, may not be produced, imported, sold or transported; imported feed must carry a radioactivity test certificate from the exporting country.
- Section 13: every package must state the maker and country of origin, the firm's registration number, the net weight, the ingredients and nutrients with their percentages, the lot number, a source code, the species the feed is meant for, and the dates of manufacture and expiry.
- Section 14: antibiotics, growth hormones, steroids, pesticides and other harmful chemicals may not be used in fish or animal feed.
- Sections 15 and 16: officials may inspect factories, stores, vehicles and records, and may seize and order the destruction of harmful or adulterated feed.
- Sections 18 to 20: courts take up cases only on the written complaint of a director general or an empowered officer; offences are non-cognizable and bailable, and the penalty is up to one year's imprisonment, a fine of up to Tk 50,000, or both.
The Act also names the laboratories whose results count. Its list of "quality control laboratories" includes those of the Department of Fisheries, the livestock department, BSTI, the Bangladesh Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, the Bangladesh Fisheries Research Institute, the Bangladesh Livestock Research Institute, the fisheries, veterinary and animal husbandry faculties of recognised universities, and the Bangladesh Atomic Energy Commission, along with any laboratory the government adds by gazette.

How BSTI came into the picture
The column's account of the second regulator began in 2018. For a long time, the writer noted, the livestock department under the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock had overseen the matter, but in 2018 BSTI, under the Ministry of Industries, moved to take it on. It issued a notification making quality certification mandatory before the sale, distribution and commercial promotion of 28 products, poultry and fish feed among them. It decided to raid factories to check feed quality and, in the writer's description, made it compulsory to take its certification marks (CM) certificate on payment of hefty fees. Fish and poultry feed makers, he wrote, found themselves under dual authority.
The Financial Express reported on 12 July 2018 that BSTI had issued two gazette notifications dated 3 July making the Bangladesh Standard (BDS) mark mandatory for 28 new products, poultry and fish feed among them, with effect from 3 September. That raised the number of products under mandatory certification from 166 to 194. Makers had to apply for a BSTI licence, and BSTI would inspect factories and test samples to check compliance, the paper reported.
BSTI itself, as Banglapedia describes it, was set up at Tejgaon in Dhaka under an ordinance of 1985 to control the quality of goods and services, and its divisions include a Certification Marks Division. In November 2018 the Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution Act 2018 (Act No. 67 of 2018) replaced the 1985 ordinance. Section 21 of that Act lets the government, after consulting the institution, ban by gazette notification the sale, distribution and commercial advertising of any product that does not follow the Bangladesh Standard set for it, from a date at least two months after publication. Section 3 says that action under the Act is in addition to, and does not curtail, action under any other law.
What a CM licence involves was set out by Prothom Alo on 10 September 2025. An applicant applies online; BSTI checks the application, inspects the factory, collects samples, has them tested in its laboratory and evaluates the report before approving. The paper listed an application fee of Tk 1,000 for a new licence and an annual licence fee of Tk 200, plus a marking fee based on the value of production, which for most products ranged from Tk 1,875 to Tk 15 lakh. The process took between 19 and 42 working days.
In the writer's account, BSTI kept pressing poultry and fish feed makers to take its CM certificate, while the producers refused to come under it or to pay large sums for the certificate. Only a handful of companies took it under heavy pressure, he wrote. Dual oversight and the fees caused discontent among company owners and raised the prospect of harassment and of higher feed prices, which, he argued, would inevitably show up in consumer prices.
The disagreement was not new. The Financial Express reported on 26 April 2021 that in March that year the fisheries and livestock ministry had asked the industries secretary to waive the mandatory BSTI CM licence for feed, arguing that the DLS was capable of issuing standardisation certificates and that the ministry which regulates poultry and livestock should also control feed. Producers told the paper that each factory and each feed item needed a separate CM licence and that the fees ran from Tk 5.0 million to Tk 40 million for each of nearly 100 feed types. The paper reported that the Bangladesh Livestock Research Institute had set up a quality control laboratory at Savar with an investment of nearly Tk 1.05 billion to test livestock products, including feed. BSTI's director in charge of certification marks told it that the institution had prepared its observations for its director general and that the government would decide.
The meeting of 3 September 2025, as the writer described it
Against this background, the column said, an important meeting was held on 3 September 2025, chaired by Farida Akhter, the adviser in charge of the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock. Senior officials of the fisheries and livestock ministry, the industries ministry and BSTI attended, along with leaders of the Feed Industries Association Bangladesh. The writer reported each side's position in quotation.
Industries ministry and BSTI officials, according to the column, said: "Tests on fish and animal feed samples have already found excessive ppm of chromium in most samples. That is why feed producers were brought under mandatory certification in 2018."
The feed makers' leaders, as quoted in the column, said that for the CM certification of each production unit BSTI had imposed VAT, marking fees and testing fees at set rates, which had hurt the sector, and that exemption was essential if the poultry sector was to grow further. They added that feed industries also make premixes and other nutrients, formulated to animals' nutritional needs, which only the livestock department's technically qualified staff (DVM/AH) could ensure; that the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock had international-standard quality control laboratories, so the livestock department could issue quality certificates; and that BSTI certification was not needed to export feed.
Officials of the fisheries and livestock ministry and its departments, in the column's account, said that section 3 of the Fish Feed and Animal Feed Act 2010 made the department concerned the controlling authority, that section 10 empowered it to set the standard levels of feed ingredients and section 11 to ensure feed quality. They said the ministry had five large quality control laboratories in Dhaka, Savar, Khulna and Chattogram, and that because fish and animal feed were governed by a special law there was no scope to require feed makers to take BSTI certification. Every government agency ran under its own laws, rules and policies, they said, and just as BSTI was a quality control body, the European Union had given accreditation certificates to the fisheries and livestock laboratories. "So why should feed makers under them have to take certificates from BSTI?" they asked.
The chair, as quoted in the column, said: "The Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock will not compromise on quality in meeting the safe nutritional needs of a growing population. But it would be proper to keep farmers and producers free of extra cost, time and dual supervision. Oversight of the same product's quality by two government agencies stands in the way of a hassle-free one-stop service. It is very urgent to let the domestic feed industry grow as a thrust sector. Otherwise employment and economic development will suffer and the country's progress will be hampered."
After the discussion, the column said, an eight-member committee was formed to assess the ministry's overall capacity, with a view to exempting poultry and fish feed from the BSTI certification requirement. The writer stated that the committee's report had been delayed and that, meanwhile, BSTI had kept up pressure on feed companies in various ways to take its licence by paying large fees, adding to their troubles. Such a situation, he argued, hindered the growth of industry. It was clear to him that both ministries wanted to oversee feed makers. He hoped that neither would be called into question for over-eagerness and that both meant well, but giving the same job to two bodies at once, he wrote, was very likely to add complications.
Chromium and tannery waste, an old concern
The chromium finding cited by BSTI officials touches a concern that had been in the courts and the press for more than a decade. Chrome-tanned leather scraps can find their way into protein concentrate for feed. On 24 July 2014 The Daily Star reported that a mobile court in Hazaribagh, Dhaka, accompanied by an upazila livestock officer of the DLS, sealed four poultry feed factories where tanned leather off-cuts and shaving dust were piled inside and sacks of poultry and fish feed were stored. The court ordered 300 tonnes of feed made from tannery scraps destroyed, and the DLS officer said the factories had no approval from the department. FIAB, the paper reported, welcomed the drive and said none of its 65 member mills used tannery waste.
The courts had acted earlier. According to The Daily Star, the High Court on 21 July 2011, on a writ filed in July 2010 by the rights group Human Rights and Peace for Bangladesh, ordered feed factories using tannery waste to be stopped and told the authorities to prepare guidelines to monitor the practice. The Appellate Division dismissed a feed maker's leave to appeal in December 2016 and upheld the High Court directive on 9 April 2017. On 2 April 2019 the High Court directed the authorities to stop poultry and fish feed factories using tannery waste across the country and asked the secretaries of five ministries, including fisheries and livestock, and the Inspector General of Police to explain why contempt proceedings should not be brought for not halting them. The same report cited a 2007 study by Dhaka University and the Bangladesh Council of Scientific and Industrial Research that found chromium in eggs and poultry meat above the tolerable level.
Peer-reviewed work put figures on the risk. A study by M. L. Bari and colleagues in the Journal of Health and Pollution in 2015 analysed skin-cut tannery waste, the poultry feed made with it and the edible parts of chickens fed on that feed. It found chromium at 0.12 to 3.11 mg/kg and lead at 8.06 to 22.0 mg/kg in the waste, chromium at 0.27 to 0.98 mg/kg and lead at 10.27 to 10.36 mg/kg in the feed, and chromium at 0.1 to 2.440 mg/kg and lead at 0.257 to 1.750 mg/kg in skin, liver, gizzard and meat. The authors concluded that heavy metals built up in chickens fed such feed and passed to people who ate them, a potential health risk to consumers.
What international guidance asks of feed makers
The international benchmark for feed safety is the Codex Alimentarius Code of Practice on Good Animal Feeding (CAC/RCP 54-2004), adopted in 2004 and amended in 2008 by the joint FAO and WHO food standards body. Its stated objective is to help ensure the safety of food for human consumption through good animal feeding at farm level and good manufacturing practice in the procurement, handling, storage, processing and distribution of feed for food-producing animals, and it expressly covers aquaculture.
The code says feed ingredients should come from safe sources and be monitored through inspection, sampling and analysis for undesirable substances, and that undesirable substances such as industrial and environmental contaminants should be identified, controlled and minimised. It asks for clear labelling, including the animals the feed is meant for, the ingredients, the manufacturer's contact details, a lot identification and the manufacturing and expiry dates, and for records that let a product be traced and recalled. Antibiotics, it says, should not be used in feed to promote growth in the absence of a public health safety assessment. It expects manufacturers to practise self-regulation and governments to run risk-based official programmes to check that feed is produced, distributed and used so that food of animal origin is safe, and it treats safe feed as the responsibility of everyone in the chain, from farmers and ingredient makers to compounders and transporters.
The writer's case for one ministry
The column's central argument was practical. If the livestock ministry kept responsibility for a healthy growing environment and for the treatment of poultry and fish while BSTI under the industries ministry controlled their feed, the writer warned, there was a risk of serious harm. When birds or fish fell sick, grew poorly or farmers lost money, each side would blame the other: one office would say the feed was substandard, the other that treatment and care were wrong. Producers might struggle to satisfy both, and the fast-growing poultry and fish industry could be pushed towards ruin.
Feed mills, he pointed out, do not make human food directly; they make food for fish and poultry, whose health depends largely on its quality, so safe fish, meat and eggs require safe feed. He then put his questions to readers: which institution should oversee the supply of safe fish, meat and eggs by ensuring safe feed, medicine and proper treatment? Was the quality of all the thousands of BSTI-approved products beyond dispute? Could any single ministry oversee everything alone? Which institution had more qualified expert staff and wider reach to supervise the whole process?
Controlling feed quality alone was not enough, the writer argued. Fish and poultry also needed proper treatment and conditions to grow healthily, which meant regular health checks, farm visits, proper care and expert advice to farmers, along with checks on any misuse of chemicals or antibiotics. That work needed the direct involvement of agricultural university graduates, and in his view there was no alternative to the fisheries and livestock ministry for it.
The writer pointed to the livestock department's field network. Livestock officers are posted in every thana or upazila and district, he noted, and their main job is to raise the output of healthy cattle, goats, poultry and fish. In his view they were qualified to build the extra capacity needed to detect adulteration in poultry and fish feed and to collect reasonable government fees; if needed, their staff should be increased, given modern training, and the number and quality of laboratories raised. Banglapedia traces the department's work back to 1893, when the British government set up a Civil Veterinary Department; after the partition of India it was reorganised as the Directorate of Animal Husbandry of East Pakistan, renamed the Directorate of Livestock Services in 1960, and it now works from Pasusampad Bhaban on Krishi Khamar Sarak, Farmgate, Dhaka, under a director general.
Alongside this, the column concluded, job opportunities for qualified agricultural university graduates should be increased, and a single ministry should be given all responsibility and accountability, which the writer considered essential for the proper growth of an expanding industry. In short, he wrote, the job of ensuring safe fish and meat for people by raising healthy cattle, goats, poultry and fish should be given to the Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, and this should be done very quickly.
Photo: Tanvir Rahat / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Sources: Jagonews24, Bangladesh Code (bdlaws, Fish Feed and Animal Feed Act 2010; Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution Act 2018), Department of Livestock Services, Department of Fisheries, The Financial Express, Prothom Alo, The Business Standard, The Daily Star, Journal of Health and Pollution, Codex Alimentarius (FAO/WHO), Banglapedia




Comments
(0)